Supernaturalville
Penname: CdeWinter78 [Contact]
Real name: Abi Ross
Status: Member
Member Since: 28/02/07
Website:
Beta-reader:

So I figure it is about time I stopped being a chicken and introduced myself, after all I have been inflicting my scribbling on you for a while now!!!!

My name is Abi, Abigail - when I am in trouble with my Mother!! I live in Merry England near Northampton (yes I paddle on THAT side of the pond!). I have one beautiful Son - who may well be the coolest person I ever met, and I have only known him for three years!!!!! LOL! And my understanding husband - who rolls his eyes resignedly at my Supernatural obsession, but indulges me anyway!

I have to say Supernatural is not my usual viewing - well not without a cushion in front of my eyes, but how can you ignore those Winchesters? It would take a stronger woman than I!!!! Finding this site has been something of a blessing. As both an avid reader and a closet scribblerI have found this site and the people I have met here to be a real treasure. It is probably a large part of the reason I came out of the shadows and had the nerve to scribble and to my HUGE astonishment - people read it!!!!! Now I am an absolute review junkie - but watching the read count go up on my stories is still the biggest thrill! So I guess I will end with a Thank you to all who take the time to read on this site - those that read and those that review, you don't know how much that makes a writers day!!!! And to the many, many far more awesome talents than mine - you feed my imagination and provide my escape, your skills are truly inspiring and you deserve the title "Unscripted Genius".  


[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by CdeWinter78
 
Eternal by Armaita Rated: T starstarstarstar [Reviews - 11]
Summary:

I read Winchester07's 'Princes of the Universe' (great story...please read hers too), and thought that Dean and Duncan's kinsman Connor should meet, because the two characters seem similar. Both are the strong, silent type, and both have a dark, determined side. Highlander crossover. Dean dies, but not all is as it seems...

Please read and review; hope you enjoy!


Categories: General, Crossovers, Action, Humor Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Head-Hunting
Chapters: 4 Completed: Yes Word count: 8790
[Report This] Published: 11/12/07 Updated: 30/12/07


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstar
Date: 31/12/07 Title: Chapter 2: The Protégé

Liked Dean's response, he has seen a lot of freakiness in his lifetime, so the fact that he plays along untill he gets the information he needs seems fitting. You have some great Deanisms along the way. Dean insisting that the "Prize" be a holiday in Tahiti for him and Sam and his response to being in the running for world power;“And last year we thought it was Sammy that would be bent on world domination.".

Very dry and very Dean.  

 



Author's Response: Thanks for the review. You're right about Dean playing along, and since he's out of his element, I included lots of sarcasm. (He would never admit it, but we know that a sarcastic Dean is usually one thrown off-balance by a situation.) Thanks again!

 
Major Arcana by irnan Rated: K starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 10]
Summary:

 

A Supernatural tarot. (Drabbles)


Categories: Drabbles Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Snapshots
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 953
[Report This] Published: 12/12/07 Updated: 12/12/07


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstar
Date: 12/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This was original - and I liked the way you had to work for some of it - kind of like interpreting the cards I guess. Some strong images and clever illustrations. I have never read the author you reference, so I may be missing something - but it still worked for me!  Enigmatic and enjoyable.

Author's Response: Hope it wasn't too much work to piece it all together... glad you liked them! And yes, if you haven't read Neil, you are missing something. He's the literary equivalent of Supernatural. Dark and twisty and funny and moving and... well, I'll stop there because really, the list could go on for quite some time.

 
Broken Images by mizpah Rated: T starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 205]
Summary:

 Broken Images new

Who was the handsome stranger brought to the mental institution in the dead of night - and what terrible tragedy from his past had reduced him to a broken, empty shell?

People's Choice Winner

Awards 2008 Best Future fic

2008 UnGen Awards Best Sam


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 6 Completed: Yes Word count: 29830
[Report This] Published: 14/12/07 Updated: 11/01/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstar
Date: 14/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Liked the suspense that kept me guessing which brother it was till the end. You draw out the passage of time and Dean's eventual resurfacing into the real world well. The Aussie Dr's treatment of him, is touching, more concerned than clinical, but the broken man you describe would inspire this I think. When he turns to her and cries it brings a real lump to your throat. Looks like another winner of a story and I can't wait till chapter two!



Author's Response: Wow - thank you so much. Yes, Kayla (Dr Bartlett) has a rather soft heart, and she sees something in her mystery patient that just calls to her mothering instincts. More angst to come - and a twist....Jules

 
Straws by dragonfly11 Rated: K starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 13]
Summary:

SPOILERS FOR 'HEART'

He was dying right there in front of Dean and with a forced and pain-filled brave smile, he was giving Dean one last second to come up with a miracle---for them all. To make everything better like he used to be able to when he was five.


Categories: General, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1032
[Report This] Published: 17/12/07 Updated: 18/12/07


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 18/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

That last scene in Heart is an amazing piece of drama and acting. It stands alone as one of the best scenes in season two, for me. The fact that you could take such a firm favorite and embelish upon it , making it more vivid if anything shows your amazing skill as a writer. Your images are powerful and the emotions you convey is right on the money! Excellent work.

Author's Response:

*bhg* Thank you so much! I know, I was a goner when "Silent Lucidity" started playing. lol

 
The Picture by sprntrl_grl Rated: K starstarstarstar [Reviews - 3]
Summary:

 

In that instant, he hated his father for not telling him what was happening, why he didn’t have a mother, why no one wanted to speak of her, why they did what they did. Wanting to somehow stick it to his father, he did the unthinkable: he left the hotel room, disobeying a direct order, and stepping over the line of salt.
Categories: General, Wee!chester Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1449
[Report This] Published: 20/12/07 Updated: 20/12/07


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstar
Date: 21/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: The Picture

Enjoyed this - kind of like Sam's initiation into the Supernatural world. What a way to learn about it! Happy that John didn't go for the bait of Sammy being the cause of Mary's death.  Your story paints a sympathetic picture of a young child who misses his mother and is trying to deal with the undercurrents of danger he feels in his world. After all Sam is not stupid. Thanks for the read.



Author's Response: Thanks. :-)

 
Summary:  Photobucket

What do you pray for - I pray for you...


Categories: General, One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 4478
[Report This] Published: 26/12/07 Updated: 26/12/07


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 27/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

You really did find inspiration on Christmas day didn't you? That was Beautiful.

 

You captured in a simple, bold, eloquent way, not only what it is like to leave home for the first time, but what Sam's experience of it could have been, having broken his ties with his family.

Totally bought Dean's response of going after Sam, following the initial fight and then his hesitation, but over ridding need to make sure his brother was alright on his first Christmas away from home.  How typically Dean - his note didn't use the chick flick "three word" moment but the most powerful four word sentence for Sam - one that would drive him to keep going and succeed at Stanford... "I'm proud of you".  Most people look to hear this from their parents, Sam needed to hear it from Dean. The fact that he keeps that note in his wallet put a lump in my throat.

You give us a beautiful, powerful rendition of a broken time in both the boys lives here. So gracefully written, I have to go find a happy place now!!!

 



Author's Response: Thank you for that. I sort of felt that Dean would be proud of his brother's achievements, even though he would miss him terribly. And that coming from Dean would have meant more to Sam, I think, seeing as it was really Dean who raised him, not John. I wanted to make that the key to him finally settling down at Stanford and embracing his new life, but Dean also letting go and letting Sam live that life. For a little while, at least. I'm really pleased that you loved it so much...Jules

 
If Life Were Fair by Birdy Rated: K+ starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 49]
Summary: Past Featured Story

Deans POV after being injured.  Dealing with an angry Sam, hyper-active wildebeest and a marshmallow obsessed sub-conscious.

 


Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 2 Completed: Yes Word count: 6407
[Report This] Published: 29/12/07 Updated: 01/01/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 31/12/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Congratulations on a great first chapter, and your first fanfiction here. I now have wildebeest migrations and marhmellows stuck in my head for the day - but your story made me chuckle, so it's all good.

Loved the view from inside Dean's head, it is very close to what I imagine goes on behind those beautiful green eyes.

This was just so satisfying - am waiting on the next chapter, just to see what can top wildebeest's in clogs and mating lemeurs !!!! 



Author's Response:

Thank you so much for such a nice review.

Sorry about the wildebeest & marshmallow problem - but hey, now you know how poor Dean feels!

Next chapter - Lemurs in clogs, mating - could turn dangerous!

Happy New Year

Kirsty x

 
Once upon a time by irnan Rated: K starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 12]
Summary: Past Featured Story

 

In another life, John never learned to hunt.


Categories: Drabbles, AU Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Snapshots
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 408
[Report This] Published: 02/01/08 Updated: 02/01/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 04/01/08 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

That was amazing. Love the balance and tempo with which you write. The "Once Upon a Time" title give us the impression that you are delivering a fairytale, and indeed three thirds of your drabble seem to follow that formula. The best elements of their Supernatural life still present with all the warm fuzzy stuff (Dean share's his first Anniversary with his brother, allowing him to make his big engagement announcement.) provides us with an even more inviting world than WIAWSNB. Loved the line "That is to say, they were always close, but never close". - worked so well in your piece.

BUT... then you go and pull the carpet out from under us with the fact that the course of Sam's life does not change even if the substance of his life does.

Brilliant work, truly deserving of the feature. I looked into your bio and am now tempted to go through your considerable body of work. (Wicked lady and your damnable awesome writing talent - I had work to do this weekend!!!! :-) ) Thanks for a great read.

 



Author's Response:

Count yourself lucky you're not on ffnet right now - I've got even more storys over there (mostly drabbles though). Should warn you: everyone who manages to read ALL my ramblings tends to go a little crazy... ;)

I find it hard to believe that Dean could have become the man we sort-of-saw in "What Is". Some things, like courage and love and bravery and self-sacrifice and the strength to do the right thing because it IS the right thing, all of which Dean has in abundance, aren't circumstantial, they're a part of your character. So if the boys had grown up 'normally', I think Dean would have been a good man and a good brother, although never quite to the extent that he is on the show.

Thanks very much for the review, glad you liked the story (how it got featured will always be a mystery to me. Who decides those things?)!

 
Summary: Past Featured StoryJohn in Hell knew exactly what was happening in Cold Oak. In fact he had known what was happening to his boys the whole time since he made the deal. Now he had the front row seat to Sam’s death and Dean’s deal. And just how did he know?? The demons in Hell made sure he knew, that’s how… 

And how did he get out??

 

Stunning banner courtesy Bulletbabe

 

Photobucket

 

With heartfelt thanks you whoever nominated my fic for Round 14 of SNFA over at Sensue Domain, and all those of you who voted. I am humbled and stoked.

 

Winner Worst Nighmare Category (Horror)

 

Runner Up Best Story from overall category winners

and then...

To win both the UnGen 08 categories this fic was nominated in is exciting and humbling. Thank you from the bottom of my heart to everyone who voted. A special hug to whoever nominated me, I am simply blown away.

siggie prize banner

 

 

 


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 5 Completed: Yes Word count: 26003
[Report This] Published: 05/01/08 Updated: 08/04/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 07/01/08 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Honestly, I had been wondering were you had gone to... now it all becomes clear. What is also crystal is what an articulate, talented and creative author you are!

This was amazing, you provide us with an utterly convincing version of John's hell. What else would be fitting for the fallen hunter but to witness the consequences not only of his deal but the path in life he chose for his boys... and not be able to do a damn thing about it. Liked the image and references to watching the scenes like a movie - the twisted hellish version of his life flashing before him? The way his unending torment feeds the evil masses around him is a powerful and disturbing image and I love the way you vary the descriptions of each new torment.

Your description of the boys low moments through their fathers eyes is brilliant work - so emotive, so full of despair and a sense of guilt and shame at his contribution to the horrors in their lives. There were just to many well turned phrases for me to list them all. But this broke my heart: "The laughing of the demons blended with the sobbing of one son and the crooning of the other. John wasn’t sure if he could hear his own sobs or his baby’s, before the demons chanting overtook it all."

The demon re-hash of events was the perfect touch - how the YED reinterpreted the events of WIAWSNB, and twisted his deceptive argument round John's broken heart.  “Suicide, John! The coward’s way out. And this is the end he sees fit in his perfect world. Now he’s watching out for Sam, improving his life!”

I can not wait to see what "the best" is - though I fear I know. Your format, tone and timing was right on the money, fitting John's anguished experience perfectly - you leave us in no doubt that for John Winchester this was beyond hell with no glimmer of relief.

Congratulations on your very well deserved feature. It has been an absolute pleasure to write this review, not only because I really did enjoy your inventive first chapter but because as a reviewer you have been such a source of support to other authors (myself amongst them) and taken such care and thought in your praise of them, that ANY opportunity to return that is one to be ceased!!

Looking out for chapter two - goes without saying;-) !!!!



Author's Response:

Such a stunning reveiw! Now it's me feeling ten feet tall!! Thank-you SO much for the detail and effort you put into this review, you have left me glowing and speechless!

The two liness you have highlighted were my favs and to know you noticed them enough to quote them is awesome.

Thanks heaps for your high praise, thoughtful comments and congrats *smiling madly*



Author's Response: PS I've just found your stars! Thanks for adding the sparkle!

 
Summary: A collection of drabbles. Chapter Nineteen: Sometimes Sam envies those who aren't afraid of the dark.


Categories: Drabbles Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 19 Completed: No Word count: 1824
[Report This] Published: 09/01/08 Updated: 25/03/09


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 1: For Satan finds some mischief still for idle hands to do

Cute - I don't think mooching around would have been part of John Winchester's school of training, and as we all know - Dean was the star pupil!! Love how he tries to be useful with the coffee, but the request to research is just really not his thing... very Usual Suspects!!! The brotherly teasing is such an endearing part of their relationship - and Dean is a master... this is right up there with the Nair stunt!!!

PS. Thanks for the definition of a drabble... can see that makes for challenging writing, you pulled it off very smoothly here!



Author's Response: Sorry, I got a little behind on responding to reviews.  Thanks for the review, I'm glad you liked it!  :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 2: Glutton for Punishment

These drabbles really focus your attention on the point at hand. Yes, what they do, their job, saves lives and the dreadful irony is that apart from a few snatched moments, their jobs denies them a life of their own. Their childhood path was set in stone, no escaping, no choice. To an extent they are set on their paths now too - Sam is a marked man, even though Yellow eyes is gone, but your right, the thought of backing down or going slower in this year doesn't even come into it. Fits perfectly with your title!!! Loved the tone you write this with and especially;

"Drain every last second of life from the miserable solitary year."



Author's Response: Thank you!  I'm glad you enjoyed it. :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 3: A Life on a Summer Breeze

Beautiful - wistful and envious. Happy to believe this is either of the boys, the thoughts you project here probably occurred to both of them at some point. How clearly you show the true cost of their lifestyle here. This broke my heart;

"Elaborate picnics with enough food to feed an army. "

How often did the boys watch from the outside, the world they protected in the shadows. Amazing work the need comes through so strongly.

 



Author's Response: Thanks.  I can't really remember which of the guys I had in mind when writing this, like you said it really can be either.  I think I had a review from someone who even suggested John which also fits.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 4: Pride Comes Before A Fall

Your writing captures feelings so strongly, and as with this piece heartbreakingly (am now making up words to describe your great work!). IMTOD was harsh in it's teasing portrayal of John's normally repressed Fatherly instincts - there could not have been a dry eye in the house when he told Dean he was proud of him. Your description of Dean's response to the praise was spot on, of course he wouldn't just accept it, but find 'confusion and concern' soon overpowered his 'warm feeling'. Very true to character.

Author's Response: Hee!  'Heartbreakingly' should so be a word!  :)  Thanks, I'm glad you liked it.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 5: Choiceless

You get right into John's thoughts here. It never occurred to me before, but such an experienced hunter must have had more than a few tricks up his sleeves - his knowledge was certainly vast, but love how you have him going with the sure thing here... because it's Dean, and now there is no choice.

Liked the way that John walks into the deal with his eyes open, almost a hint at him manipulating the Demon here;

"John knew this evil intimately, knew what it wanted, what buttons to push."

Nice touch. Great picture of a Father's devotion to something other than his need for revenge.



Author's Response: Thank you!  I'm glad I seem to have managed to convey what I was trying to.  :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 6: He was supposed to say don’t be afraid of the dark

I don't necessarily see this as the Winchester's introduction to the world of hunting, but possibly any hunters introduction. It's beautifully written 'End of Innocence' and I can STILL recall thinking the edge of the bed thing!!!! LOL. Your last line is sadly true for all of us with the most difficult challenges we face in life. You have an amazing view of the world.. I think they call it a writer's eye?  Love that your pieces can be taken on more than one level.



Author's Response: Thank you.  *blushes*  A lot of people have said, like you, that they can really relate to this because they did similar things as a child.  As for the writer's eye *blushes again*, thank you so much.  I'm glad you enjoy my drabbles so much.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 7: No Car Go

Clever title. Nice snapshot of where Dean was in the aftermath of Sam leaving. Posses a clue as to why there are so many women - for Dean family is first, last and every point in-between, for his family, there are always other complications... lonely place to find yourself to be. Very sad.

Author's Response: Thank you!  If you'd like to read more I expanded this one into a one shot that you can find on my profile page (it's also called No Car Go.)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 8: State of Conscience

Like the metaphor, washing away the blood not as easy as clearing the conscience. Sam's medical judgement at a glance that Dean needed watching over was a nice addition. Loved this descriptive;

"Exhaustion had seeped to his bones and movement seemed like wading through molasses"

Nice that you bring home the fact that the hunt doesn't end when the evil thing is disposed off - the aftermath includes the needed repairs... whether physical or psychological.



Author's Response: Thank you!  I'm also working on expanding this one into a one shot.  It's not posted yet but hopefully will be in the not too distant future.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 9: Little Green Men

Exactly!!!! How on earth (or in the heavens!!!;-) ) could they bear their lives if this weren't true. The image of them being so in-sync is very cute - the fact that Sam checked makes it 100 times more so and clearly marks him as the younger sibling. It's the little touches in your brilliant drabbles that make them come to life and stand alone.

Author's Response: Thank you!  I have to admit the added limit of 100 words means that every word has to pull its weight so I'm glad you like the little touches.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 10: Big Night Last Night

Love your brotherly moments - you have this knack of just nailing the sentiment and dialogue!!! Loved the image of Sam throwing up his organs!!!! (UGGGHHH!) Must have been one WILD night, thanks to Dean ... and because of big brother Sam gets to live to tell about it!!!!

Author's Response: Thanks!  Getting the brotherly moments right is probably one of the best compliments that a Supernatural writer can get.  And yeah, Dean would definitely show Sam a good night on his birthday!  :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 11: Probabilities

Awesome first paragraph - clever stuff. Though it's Dean's life on the line, Sam is suffering too. Enjoyed how you painted Sam's under-currant of thoughts, especially when Dean crashes. There is something very matter of fact about them. Maybe it has to do with all the times they have faced similar scenario - but the all too human and desperate plea at the end just goes to prove your first paragraph. Like I said - clever stuff.

Author's Response: Thank you.  This was a new style of writing for me so I'm glad it seems to have worked.  :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 12: Safe Haven

LOVED THIS - glad there is more lurking out there!!! LOL!

The urgency communicated by Sam (the wordsmiths) miserly use of words and your great description of;

"It’s like a bucket of ice, a shot of adrenaline and gallon of caffeine all at once".... makes this instantly attention grabbing.

The fact that Deacon has the very human response of ticking off all the reasons he shouldn't but still comes off the fence to help makes you warm to him even more. Intriguing stuff. These drabbles are diabolical devices - they keep adding to my reading list!!!! LOL!



Author's Response: Thanks!  I'm glad you enjoyed it.  At least drabbles are only 100 words so they're quick reading.  ;)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 20/03/08 Title: Chapter 13: Making the Grade

Like how your mind takes off - this response to 'acid test', very creative. Also quite a believable snapshot of what happened before Dean's first hunt... of course John would have run him into the ground and listened hard for any telltales that his boy wasn't ready. Come on Johnny!!!! That's just not how you made the boy?!!!! (Ever get the impression that John succeeded with Dean beyond his worst imaginings?!!!)

Have thoroughly enjoyed your collection of exceptionally well crafted drabbles. They are inventive and controlled - true to character and creative in the directions they take the reader in - fantastic job, Thanks for the read!!!



Author's Response:

Thank you!  I'm glad you enjoyed them.  I'll be adding to them now and again if you want to keep an eye out.

I think John quite possibly didn't realise entirely what he was doing with Dean.  I wanted to convey with this drabble, and I'm not sure if I succeeded (I'm thinking not) that John pushes Dean hard not only to make sure he's ready but out of protection.  He's not taking his boy with him if he can't protect himself.

 
bleed into me by leahk80 Rated: K starstarstarstar [Reviews - 7]
Summary: something from the heart
Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 29
[Report This] Published: 09/01/08 Updated: 09/01/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 16/12/08 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

So few words, uncertain meaning - but it leaves powerful impression. I don't think it matters which brother or when, their lives become so entwined - it's kind of the point for me ... they do "bleed into each other".

Great Work.



Author's Response:

thanks for your review. sorry my response is so late.

leah

 
Summary: What Sam and Dean could be thinking after the Season 2 finale.
Categories: General, Drabbles Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 252
[Report This] Published: 22/01/08 Updated: 26/01/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 21/02/08 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This was a very controlled piece, but you somehow manage to convey some of the brothers deepest thoughts in such a short space.

Loved this from Dean; "I say I have to because to say they're optional means there is room to fail in my tasks. I cannot fail." The idea that he feels any greatness he may have, has been swallowed by the needs of others - great image.

Also from Sam;"So I do the little things to try to bring a smile to your face. The little things that make us as normal as we can be."

I like how you capture their bond through the fact that they both end with the same conclusion ... though I think Sam only arrived at this realisation after rejoining Dean.

Enjoyed this your first fan fiction, it was very inventive.



Author's Response: Thanks!  I really appreciate the feedback.  I agree that Sam's pov isn't as cohesive as Dean's but hopefully this means that whatever I do next will be better.  :D  Thanks again!  I'm glad you liked it!

 
Summary:

Set after BUABS. There is no rest for the weary. An old friend and a new hunt pits Dean against the elements and Sam against himself as the brothers fight for each other and for survival. T for language and themes.

Banner by bulletbabe.


Categories: General, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 99433
[Report This] Published: 29/01/08 Updated: 04/05/08


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 19/02/08 Title: Chapter 1: Watch

Exciting to see a multi-chapter from you. From the sounds of your workload - you have been busy, but don't worry your story legs are right where you left them, firmly under you!!

This was a good start - action packed right from the beginning. As often happens with your work I enjoyed the dimension you give to your secondary characters they make the reader want to find out more about them. Your keen eye for detail is still active in your beautiful descriptive, and you capture the brothers dynamic so well - even to anticipating what the fallout from BABS would be in a tangible, believable way.

It's so polished and the timing of action sequences and angsty guilt trips... good to have you back Gaelic!



Author's Response:

Hi Winter -- my apologies for missing this review earlier. I didn't see a notice for it.

Thank you so much for reading and taking time to review. I really appreciate it. I feel honored that you think it's good to have me back. I hope you continue to enjoy this story!

Gaelic