Supernaturalville
Penname: CdeWinter78 [Contact]
Real name: Abi Ross
Status: Member
Member Since: 28/02/07
Website:
Beta-reader:

So I figure it is about time I stopped being a chicken and introduced myself, after all I have been inflicting my scribbling on you for a while now!!!!

My name is Abi, Abigail - when I am in trouble with my Mother!! I live in Merry England near Northampton (yes I paddle on THAT side of the pond!). I have one beautiful Son - who may well be the coolest person I ever met, and I have only known him for three years!!!!! LOL! And my understanding husband - who rolls his eyes resignedly at my Supernatural obsession, but indulges me anyway!

I have to say Supernatural is not my usual viewing - well not without a cushion in front of my eyes, but how can you ignore those Winchesters? It would take a stronger woman than I!!!! Finding this site has been something of a blessing. As both an avid reader and a closet scribblerI have found this site and the people I have met here to be a real treasure. It is probably a large part of the reason I came out of the shadows and had the nerve to scribble and to my HUGE astonishment - people read it!!!!! Now I am an absolute review junkie - but watching the read count go up on my stories is still the biggest thrill! So I guess I will end with a Thank you to all who take the time to read on this site - those that read and those that review, you don't know how much that makes a writers day!!!! And to the many, many far more awesome talents than mine - you feed my imagination and provide my escape, your skills are truly inspiring and you deserve the title "Unscripted Genius".  


[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by CdeWinter78
 
Iron Will by Ridley James Rated: K starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 43]
Summary: Pre-Series. Dean and Sam are mistakenly sent on a hunt by their father only to find out too late that evil isn't reserved for the supernatural.
Categories: General, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 5 Completed: Yes Word count: 24151
[Report This] Published: 08/03/09 Updated: 19/04/09


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 13/05/09 Title: Chapter 5: Chapter 5

Great tale- was hooked the whole way through. Are there plans to write the Zombie back story?  Sounds like gripping stuff. My favorite part here - aside from Dean in full smart mouth mode was the Mac/John interaction - interesting to glance into that relationship.

Satisfying - I was having Brotherhood withdrawals!!!!!

 
Summary:

The Winchester trap and kill a witch but she has some disturbing news for Sam before she dies. Has she hex'd his brother and if she has how does he help him? Can Sam and his father stop arguing long enough to help Dean or will their constant quarrelling be the end of him? And what will be the aftermath of it all.

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!

Spoilers: Set in Pre-S1

Disclaimer:It all belongs to Mr Kripke and the CW.


Categories: General, AU Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 57 Completed: Yes Word count: 183215
[Report This] Published: 09/03/09 Updated: 19/02/10


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 12/04/09 Title: Chapter 1: Hex

Really enjoyed this begining - like the possibilities of where it might be heading. Know what you mean about the adictivness of hurting Dean - sooo wrong yet sooo much fun !!!!!

The Witch's logic in striking Dean was spot on in order to bring down the Winchester family, and like that whole lingering doom vibe you have going. Dean is written very convincingly here as are the tension's between John and Sam.

Am egar to read on ... unfortunately I have work and will have to savor this tomorrow - loooking forward to it though!!!!! Thanks for the read!

Abi.



Author's Response:

Hi Abi

Thanks for the lovely review, glad that you like the start of this, hurting Dean shouldn't be as much fun as it is, you're right there!

Pleased that you like the tension between John and Sam and the way Dean is. Sometimes it's hard to find your beat with them.

Work is a pain, hoped it passed quickly! Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 2: One minute you're down and then next you're up

Loved the Fatherly tenderness surfacing here. I don't often take that reading with John, but it's believable the way you write it.

Love how Dean can read his family so well, even when he is dealing with his own stuff.

 



Author's Response:

Hi there

Thanks. I actually like John to a certain point and I think that deep down he worries constantly about what he has done to his sons.

Dean is very tuned in to the feelings of his dad and his brother, and he always tries to put them first.

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 3: Hello Pain My Old Friend

There are so many things this story has going for it. The tension between John and Sam is well written - and pretty important here...???? (waggles eyebrows)

Also the role reversal of the brothers - with Sam doing the wet nursing for once.

And OMG - Puking Blood????!!! You know how to crank the tension lady.



Author's Response:

Hi there

I love the tension between the two, one of my favourite scenes is from season 2 DMB when they are fighting and Dean has to step in, that is my inspiration for this!

Nice to see Sam caring for his brother for a change. And Blood? Never a good sign!

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 4: Waiting for a break.

Nice job with all the reserch on the medical side of things. Added that solidity to this chapter.

Thought Dean's response to finding himself in hospital was SPOT ON - an very funny!!!! :-)

Loved this;

"Dean huffed. “So you’re gonna make me have a scope and a scan done just to give you time to do research? Thanks.”  

“Watch you don’t fall over that lip and hurt yourself again.” Sam decided to join the conversation."

LMAO!!!!! Your interplay between characters is magic. It flows very easily.

Hope this new lead - you know leads them to something, as I am starting to feel sorry for the pummeling your giving our boy ... eh that was not permission to STOP by the way!!!!! LOL 



Author's Response:

HI there

I liked writing Dean wanting to escape and Sam was very cruel to his poor brother!

I love it when people feel sorry for Dean, means I'm doing something right! And I haven't actually laid a hand on his in this one which is unusual.

Couldn't stop if I wanted to....its an addiction, I need help...seriously. *laughs insanely*

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 5: Dying To Be Right

Oooooh using the Old Man's first name - Sammy enjoys living dangerously doesn't he? But like how they seem to be pulling it together and co-operating for the sake of saving Dean.

You have many great lines in this chapter - pointed Winchester humor I call it ; the idea of Dean wanting to actually scratch his "brain itch" - great imagery. Also what has the ring of Classic Papa Winchester to it, this gem;

"“Whatever your brother is doing, tell him to get that ass of his back into a bed before I come down there and kick it.” "

Typical Dean - rushing in to solve the mystery and then reaping the consequences. Very well written medical paragraph - again. You really get the essence of the panic and the pain that Dean feels.

Sam explaining where his frustration comes from is so plausible you have to feel for him - but at the same time right now I just want him to get calm and figure out the puzzle before time runs out for Dean.

Continues to be suspenseful and thrilling ride.

PS. 3am ???? Your dedication paid off on this one !!!!  



Author's Response:

HI there

Sam is pushing John, that can't be good.

I liked the brain scratching too...typical Dean somehow!

Glad you like the guys in this chapter, it's one of the ones that I feel I've managed to capture them.

I love Dean but sometimes he is an idiot, especially when it comes to himself, I'd have just told my brother...but not Dean...no, too easy! lol

Hope you enjoy the rest of the ride, it's is almost there!

Yeah and 3am only time I get peace to think, I know how Sam feels in this.

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 6: Where do we go from here?

Ok you wiped the smug right off my face! I had guessed the outline of the anger thing - but not the car as a weapon. What wickedly clever logic thatWitch deployed - reasoning that the car was also "Family" and would also cause Dean's demise. Nice twist.

Oh and that 'Obscuera' thing - genius! As is using the hex as the way round all those pesky medical details - must remember that one.

Graet chapter - looking forward to Jim - and maybe Caleb and Bobby?



Author's Response:

HI there

Yeah the anger is the trigger but the car has a role to play too just not the one that I've set you up to think it does!

I love other people's stories with all the medical details in them but I know my limits! Besides what is the point in having the hex if you can't alter the truths a little bit?*smiles*

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 7: So close and yet

Almost there Sammy - is it bad that I need to give him a huge SHOVE?!!!

Butting heads really is like a second form of communication for John and Sam isn't it? This fact makes your plot work so well.

Hope Dean survived their last spat!



Author's Response:

Hi there

Feeling frustrated with Sam is where I want you to be, that way you know why him and John are butting heads, not that they really need an excuse.

Dean surviving.....yeah now about that....

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 8: Almost got to where we are going

Like your bussiness like version of Jim and the comradere between him and John.

How frustrating that must have been for Dean - and now they think they have all the pieces of the puzzle - hmmm looks like choppy waters ahead.

Story continues to have me riveted.



Author's Response:

Hi

John needs someone in this, Dean's out of it and Sam's mad at him, so he needs a voice of reason and calm.

Glad you are liking! MAry x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 9: Hunters or the hunted

Dean admitting that his family fighting broke his heart brought a lump to my throat because I believe he is the type that would rather chew out his own tongue than admit anything remotely tied to emo moments!!! The way he truly can't win in the Winchester family civil war is very clearly demonstrated - nice job, you can't help but feel for him.

Happy that Jim has figured it out - hope he can run like the wind before John and Sam really get into it!

 



Author's Response:

Hi

I wrote like one of those things that Dean just says sometimes when his guard is down. He can't win where his family are concerned 'cos he loves them both in different ways.

Jim is a very slow runner by the way.

Cheers Mary x

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 10: Arresting Behaviour

OMG .... NOT A DEATH FIC?!!!!!!!!

You realize that your fingers have typed the Dr calling time and everything - hell they made John Winchester CRY!!!!!! Gonna trust you though - ...

Before that huge cliff edge you threw us I was marveling at the angry exchange between John and Sam. Amazing writing - tension was perfect, reactions of both was very believable and throwing in the threat of Dean going with Sam - can imagine that was the biggest red rag of them all.

This was excellent - brutal and so fitting;

“Over my dead body.” John stood and rounded on Sam. 

Sam didn’t flinch. “Better yours than his.” 

Great Work Mary - you are an EVIL genius!!!! The story is awesome! Thanks for the exciting Read. Abi.



Author's Response:

Hi

WHAT! It's not!

Aah you see the doc only LOOKED at his watch to check the time...he didn't get to call it! I made John cry...why does that make me soo happy?

I loved that line in the fight too. I wrote the first one and the next one just screamed at me to follow it!

Evil genuis! I like! *chortles and rubs hands*

Mary xx

 
Summary:

A sort of tag for season 4 episode "In the Beginning". John looks at his eldest and sees an old memory. Set pre-series. John's POV. Spoilers for season 4.


Categories: Missing Scenes, One Shots, General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1123
[Report This] Published: 12/04/09 Updated: 12/04/09


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 14/04/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Wonderfuly thought provoking piece - you draw the threads together skillfully. Liked the mention of the New Orleans gig from the piolet - would that this WAS John's motivation for taking off.

From someone who has trouble finding a sympathethic reading of John - this really worked for me. I believed the tenderness of his emotions and the genuine misunderstandings that drove one son away and crushed the other.

Welcome back!!!! ;-) Thanks for the read. Abi.

 
Future by lostatc Rated: T starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 21]
Summary: AU.  Spoilers up to season 4 episode 18.  Dean and Sam have been separated for five years after not being able to resolve their differences. Sam comes to Dean for help on a hunt for a demon.
Categories: AU Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 7 Completed: Yes Word count: 39164
[Report This] Published: 13/04/09 Updated: 18/04/09


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 16/04/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Great start to what promises to be an amazing story. There was just so much going on here to hold the attention.

I like your style and pace of storytelling. You moved easily between past and present and left just enough questions in both time zones to leave the reader eager to follow the tale your spinning.

Intrigued by Dean "Rocking the white picket fence" - and on a sappy level, the visual of Dean with the baby was a big plus!!! LOL. The mirroring of the beginning of the Winchester adventures was masterfully done and loved the way Sam actively uses this to gain his brother's help. One of my favorite aspects is how future Dean has evolved - loved the power behind this;

"“Don’t you dare pull that crap on me.” Dean’s voice raised in anger. “I gave everything to you. I gave you my childhood, I gave you my love, and I gave you my life. I will not, Sam, I will not give you my family. You’ve done nothing but take from me. I owe you nothing.”"

It truly is through the looking glass stuff - especially with Sam wearing Big brothers personality and all.

Similarly the past is very well written the tension between the brothers is so palpable - that I'm going to end here and check out the next chapter!!! LOL

Great Start.

Abi 



Author's Response:

Abi,

Thank you so much.  It all started with the idea of Sam breaking into Dean's house and pulling him away, much the way Dean had with Sam.  It also started from the mention in a message board, "What would Sam do if Dean actually left?"  It was an idea that really intrigued me.  These two have such a co-dependant relationship, what would either of them do if the other just quit the co-dependence cold turkey?

The line you quoted, I hope people take it the way it's meant.  I don't mean that Sam had anything to do with the sacrifices Dean made, obviously he didn't cause any of that to happen.  It's just accusatory language and the way people often relate to each other.  John set Dean on his path and Sam used that to his full advantage, as any child would. 

Anyway, thank you.  I really appreciate everything you've said here, it really means a lot to me.

Hope you continue to enjoy the rest.  Its seven chapters long and I'm posting a new chapter every day.  You won't have long to wait until the end.

Kim

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2

You continue to augment the present with the past in a fluid way. Both time zones have so much going on in them.

In the past - the tension between the brothers is palpable and cuts through those tight bonds of brotherhood we all look upon as unbreakable. The way you write Ruby's character is spot on in my estimate - she is like a permanent thorn in the most venerable spot in Dean's defences. She appears to have slithered into the growing space between him and Sam.

Does that language mean anything? Nice touch that Demons would have their own language and that Dean might recognize it from hell. The betrayal was brutal - Sam under the influence definitely, but leading himself there. Equally powerful is Dean's rebuttal that Sam is gaining all this power for him. Really superbly well written.

The future is being played out nicely too, it's the small touches that give this story it's solidity. For instance that bit about changing the combination locks - it speaks to Sam clearer than the six or seven times his brother tells him to get lost. Meg is also a great device - her history with Dean gets his immediate attention.

Story has me on the very edge of the seat - and just who is that masked chick Dean runs to?!!!!

Onward ....



Author's Response:

The Poem, I found out recently, was written by a Italian Poet.  Very famous.  It's called "Inno A Satana" (Hymn to Satan).  I'm assuming it's Italian but I've no idea.  If you're curious it was written by Giosue Carducci and it's much, much longer.  Now for the confession...I didn't know any of this when I found the poem.  I found it on the Church of Satan website -- not because I have leanings that way but because I was curious.  I have the translation, I know what it says but decided if anyone wanted to know, they'd ask. 

Anyway, thank you so much for your reviews.  I love long, detailed reviews, they always make me think. 

Kim

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Really loving this story - the way you weave your explanations out of the past gives your present tale more substance.Liked the hunt within the hunt here - the back-story of Elizabeth and Dean is entertaining on its own. I had (foolishly) guessed at the blonde lady being Jo - I think her second name was Beth? But I realize that the teenager did not fit into that at all. Can't wait to see where your path takes us.Dean's injuries were pretty horrific - but described well, conveyed the extent of the damage and ultimately Dean's motivation to stay off Sam's radar. You are a very gifted storyteller - and finding this gem is a real treat. Thanks for the read! Abi 

Author's Response:

Thank you so very much.  I am flattered by your compliments.  I hope this never disappoints.

And yes, Joanna Beth but not the same person.

Kim

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 17/04/09 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 4

You have outdone yourself. That must have been so challenging to write and yet it flowed effortlessly. The torture scene and Dean's approach to it really had me seeing this terrifying broken, dangerous creature forged in hell - stellar writing really!

Like the pace of the relationship between Dean and Elizabeth - the way he clings to her for forgiveness because she gave him back some semblance of himself - wonderful stuff.

Keep repeating myself Mary but you are doing a wonderful job on this - it has everything, action, pace, intrigue and such a depth of emotion. I count it as time very well spent and look forward to the last chapter.

Great read. Abi.



Author's Response:

I like that.  Describing Dean as a creature forged in hell.  When he's pushed that way I think he's really no longer the person he once was, no matter how much he wishes he was.  I think he needs to resolve his old self with his new self before he'll be happy. 

Thanks again.  I'll have the next chapter up tomorrow and the final chapter up on Sunday.  Hope the end doesn't disappoint.

 
Summary: Feature

The boys are investigating mysterious disappearances in logging country. Is there something supernatural in the woods? Is that what’s taken Dean? Set sometime before Season 4. New chapters added by request.

Not So Drunk as You Think I Am banner


Categories: General, One Shots, Drabbles, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 28 Completed: No Word count: 5804
[Report This] Published: 18/05/09 Updated: 19/07/12


Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 26/05/09 Title: Chapter 1: Three sheets to the wind?

Yeah brevity is not a skill of mine either - but you've handled the challenge well!!

This was good - the 100 words gives it that extra sense of urgency and really works here.

Abi



Author's Response: Hey there! Thanks for coming over to check out my drabble. I'm glad you liked it, and that the sense of urgency really came through. A lot of people asked for more of the story, so  I did a follow-up chapter. Hope you'll check it out and let me know what you think! :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed
Date: 26/05/09 Title: Chapter 2: "Steady, big brother. I gotcha."

Really enjoyed this chapter. You might even be selling me on the "less is more" concept. It almost distills the situation you are writing - if you have to be sparing with your words, I guess you search harder for the more apt and meaningful ones.

Like the promise of impending Sam retribution!!

Another great chapter.

Abi



Author's Response:

Hey there, Abi! Thanks for coming back to check out another chapter of my drabble fic. I really appreciate the great review you left. 

Yeah, it took me a while to really take to the "less is more" concept. It is totally the opposite of how I usually write. LOL

But you're right--it does really distill the situation and you have to be really precise with word choices since you have so few available to you. I don't even want to admit to you how long it takes me to get one of these little drabbles done--or how much of that time is spent combing through the dictionary/thesarus, looking for a word with just the right nuance to convey what I need it to. It's definitely a challenge!

Hey if you're interested, I just started another writing experiment you might like to read. I'm using a bunch of different parameters in that one, one of which is a word limit, but the chapters are longer than drabble-length. Anyway, if you're interested, I'd love to hear what you think. It's called "Always With You" and the first chapter's up now.

Thanks again for reading and reviewing, it means a lot to me. Another chapter of this will go up in a few days, probably on Monday. Hope to see you back here then! :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 1: Three sheets to the wind?

Thrilling start - not fazed at all for the word count. You still manage to deliver the blow that has the reader rushing for the "next" button!! :)

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 2: "Steady, big brother. I gotcha."

Like the way you catalogue their emotions. It cuts straight to where we need to be (without all those flowery words I think you must be missing... trust me though your tale is not lacking because they are!!) Action Sammy is a great way to end here.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 3: Vigil

The words that stayed in from your origional draft are well selected. Enjoyed "gritty, drought-dry eyes" - fabulous!!

Also the way you weave his injuries into this giving us hints at what may have happened to him, really works. But your master stroke has to be the disoriented state that stems from Dean's concussion... of course he's using fewer words!! Crafty - and well crafted.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 4: Goodwill worn away

Loggers? Really? Hmm would not have guessed that. Still your descriptives are amazing here- especially when you describe Sammy's eyes. But my favorite has to be "Goodwill worn away by brotherly love", it plays to the very heart of the dark roads their family devotion takes each of them in the cannon.

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 5: Logger Alert

You keep the story moving well despite the word count. The fight scene works, a real accomplishment! 

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 6: Belly of the beast

Enjoyed the double drabble - for me I thought your story was getting there, though perhaps this part of your tale needed more fleshing out (no pun intended). So ham fisted Loggers working for something tall dark and toothy??? More like it - don't really know why that didn't quite sit with me, the fact that Dean was taken out by humans. Of course it would have happened often with their lifestyle!

Liked the progression of his thoughts as he realizes where he is - practical panicker Dean's first thoughts (maybe afet ouch?) is that Sammy was spared this, very in character!

 
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 04/11/09 Title: Chapter 7: Out of time

You just have totip your hat to any piece that starts out with a "bone torch" and a shadowy creature whose "pores ooze malice"!!!! Beautiful descriptives, love the true to life description of the creature coming towards him as seen by (bone) torchlight.