Supernaturalville
Penname: Gumnut [Contact]
Real name: Nutty
Status: Member
Member Since: 22/02/07
Website: http://gumnut.livejournal.com
Beta-reader:

Sometimes artist, sometimes writer, alltimes nuts.

I've written in several other fandoms including Stargate SG-1, Knight Rider and Star Trek Original, but am only just now making my way into Supernatural. Consequently, I have a huge and wonderful backlog of reading to get through which is distracting me from writing much at all :D

One other thing I should probably mention is that I'm an Aussie, born and bred, and consequently, like Kitt, I always seem to have the Impala driving on the wrong side of the road.

Anyway, I'm also a babbler and sometimes have difficulty in shutting up. Feel free to poke me anytime. I don't bite...though I have been known to chew on good fic for hours :D

Nutty
(off the edge, but learning to fly)

PS: A 'gumnut' is the woody fruit of a eucalypt, I'm not into chewing gum in any way :D


[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by Gumnut
 
Summary:

After Dean's revelation in Croatoan Sam struggles to carry on, but little does he know that his brother has a nightmare of his own that will soon prove to be even scarier than either Winchester could have known.

It's time for the Winchesters to face their demons...


Categories: AU Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 13 Completed: Yes Word count: 34783
[Report This] Published: 22/12/06 Updated: 31/01/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 1: Prologue

Holy crap and ouch!  ::runs off to read next bit::

Nutty
(well, that was a sharp introduction to your writing :D)

PS: Well written too...::hurries off to read more before brain explodes:: 

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 1

So Dean remembers, huh?  I'd often wondered what he'd think if he did.  The man must be carrying around ten different kinds of guilt over two other people dying in order for him to live.  Poor Dean's insides must be so screwed up.

Nicely written stuff.  Thanks for writing.  ::runs off to read next bit::

Nutty
(who is curious as to where you got your pen name from)



Author's Response:

Hi

I have a love for KITT the car from Knight Rider. Just loved it as a kid. Hence the crazy pen name!

Thanks for reading :)

Dawn  

  

 

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 2

Now this was like watching the show.  I think you caught the elements of the boys really well here.  Particularly with the banter...I could hear the doors of the Impala clanking shut and see the two of them walking in their suits...Dean fighting with the tie :D  Great stuff!

Nutty
(onto the next bit to find out about the spooky stuff :D)

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 3

Oh, your characterisations are great :D  I'm thoroughly enjoying this.

Though I have to say that although I've seen up to 2.15 of the series, I get the feeling I'm either forgetting something or have missed something.  Are there references to other eps in this story or is it referencing fanon or are the names of the demons for this fic only?  Sorry, I can be a bit slow on the uptake and I'm new to this fandom.

But other than that, this fic could be an episode ::eagerly reads some more::

Nutty
(who loves a clear image like the one you're implanting in my brain :D)



Author's Response:

Nope, you haven't missed anything on the show. I took Kripke's basic idea, along with the sigil John used in IMTOD and expanded on it.

Some of the stuff is totally AU from in my head and online demon facts.

Dawn :)  

 

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 28/02/07 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 12

Okay, that was just damn excellent.  Wonderfully written, well plotted, worthy of an episode.  I enjoyed it a hell of a lot :D

I loved the angst, the relationship between the boys.  You had it all down beautifully :D

Oh, and regarding the question about your username....I come to Supernatural fandom direct from Knight Rider fandom :D  So, my eyes lit up the moment I saw your name.  I could always point you in the direction of some fics ::evil grin::

But anyway, back to your fic.  I loved it and I'm now halfway through your first episode fic.  (I would have replied to this fic earlier, but my computer had a spasm).

Thanks so much for writing.

Nutty
(who has marked you as a favourite :D)



Author's Response:

Hi Nutty!

Thanks again for the compliments. It's very unusual to find KR finds in this fandom too, so its nice to see another one around!

I mostly work on the Supernatural VS, but do get the odd chance to post on here or write SN fics for fanzines!

See you around!

Dawn :)    

 

 
Take / Give by irismay42 Rated: T starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 11]
Summary: There's been a lot of give and take in Dean's life. He's given a lot, while a lot has been taken. Spoilers for In My Time of Dying. Angst. Deancentric. One shot.
Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1568
[Report This] Published: 26/12/06 Updated: 26/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 11/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I think I'm gonna cry :(  Ouch, ouch and more ouch.

Dean is so tied to family, so continually living in a fear he won't admit to.

Dean without Sam is not a pretty picture...he would erode away so fast...probably fall to darkness and his own despair.

You've illustrated his character so well it hurts.

You're a damn good writer.  I hope you know that.

Thanks for sharing, I look forward to more :D 

Nutty
(happily paddling around in a sea of Irismay fic :D)



Author's Response: Ooh, paddle away!!  I was a bit over-angsty when I wrote this one!

 
Summary: What if things happened differently in Faith, and Sam was left alone...or is he?

Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1665
[Report This] Published: 26/12/06 Updated: 26/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 02/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

::cracks up::  Absolutely hilarious.  Death would most certainly not be an impediment for the two brothers.  And they are so joined at the hip :D

A great take on what could have been such a sad moment.

Thanks for writing.

Nutty
(who still hasn't written any SPN fic but is getting close)



Author's Response:

Hi Nutty

Thanks for all your reviews. There won't be any more freelance stories for awhile as I'm busily working on the second season of the VS. So keep your eyes peeled for that! 

And I say go for it! Write and post! We're all fic lovers here. :)

Dawn  

 

 
The Gift by kittsbud Rated: K starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 9]
Summary: It's Christmas, but Dean might be holding something back from his brother. (Set after Faith, but written before the episode aired)

Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1730
[Report This] Published: 26/12/06 Updated: 26/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 02/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

A gun, a book and a pair of glasses.  This was a lovely moment between the boys.

Plus dean's reaction to the glasses was such classic Dean :D

Thanks for writing.

Nutty

(who read this a couple days ago, but hasn't had a chance to post a review until now) 

 
The Ride by kittsbud Rated: K+ starstarstarstar [Reviews - 2]
Summary: Sam and Dean meet a young girl with a secret, but they could never imagine the ghostly journey she takes them on - and all because they picked up a hitchhiker one lonely night in the desert...

Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 6 Completed: Yes Word count: 17868
[Report This] Published: 26/12/06 Updated: 26/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 02/03/07 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6

I enjoyed this fic immensely.  I love how you've characterised the brothers, particularly how Dean tends to attempt to seduce women even when he is unconscious :D

This was a great read with a good plot and plenty of Deanwhump :D

Thanks so much for writing.

Nutty

(who has read all your fics here and is now going through the virtual seasons thoroughly excited when I see your name :D) 

 
Summary: Nightmares, bishops, eggs and rain...lots of rain... Can Sam and Dean save a small town from a flood of Biblical proportions? A blatant but completely unintentional attempt to claim the Winchesters for England...
Categories: Misc Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 9 Completed: Yes Word count: 23974
[Report This] Published: 29/12/06 Updated: 29/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 11/03/07 Title: Chapter 9: Chapter 9

I've followed you here from the Virtual Seasons, where I fell in love with your stories.  Always filled with excellent plot, your fics also have something else which separates them out from others.  Yours have such an emotional soul written into them.  You illustrate the relationship between the brothers backed by great plot.  You have their banter down pat and I am eager to read the rest of the fics you have here :D  :: eyes them hungrily :D ::

As for this fic individually, I loved the English element and the detail you went to in setting up the plot.

On a side note, I have driven through a sudden rain front as you describe there and it is the bizarrest thing.  From dry to chundering rain in a second...though in my case it was more a fluke of geography than anything supernatural :D

Anyway, before I start babbling on for the next couple of hours, I'd just like to say that I thoroughly enjoyed this fic, thank you for writing and I hope you are still writing so my greedy eyes can soak up some more in the future :D

Nutty
(off to devour yet more of your fic :D)



Author's Response:

Hah hah - stalked from the VS!!  Well I'll be back there soon for Season 2!  (Hopefully - if I can manage to write more than a teaser!)

I'm glad you enjoyed this one - it's probably my least favourite, although it gets better towards the end!

 
Summary: Dean is haunted by the flashback from a hunt that took place while Sam was at Stanford. He can't remember the details but what he can't recall can hurt him.
Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 11 Completed: Yes Word count: 26504
[Report This] Published: 29/12/06 Updated: 11/02/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 11: Chapter 11 Hunt Part 2: Perception of Reality

I have to say that the thought of Dean with half his guts hanging out is a powerful image.  OOOOOOOUCH!!!  And poor Sam gets put through the wringer in this one too.  Imagine driving 50 miles with your one and only brother hanging on the edge of life and bleeding all over the car next to you.

But Dean, yes, wonderful Dean - you are truly evil to him :D  

I love how your stories have plot and good plot at that.  I know I can read it and expect a twist at the end :D

Thanks so much for writing, I enjoyed that thoroughly.

Nutty

(feeling her way into a new fandom) 



Author's Response: I will admit I love Dean but i never want to ignore Sam. I'm glad you liked it! Hope to see you on the VS site! 

 
Summary:

Following John's coordinates, the boys prepare to battle a witch. When they discover a greater evil is at work, can Sam save Dean's life or will his brother's pain become his own?


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 53269
[Report This] Published: 30/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 18/04/07 Title: Chapter 8: The Journey's The Thing

Okay, now I'm going to have to back and re-read all the other ones again to get them all straight in my head.

I really enjoyed the introduction of Brenna in this.  Of course, I was viewing it from a perspective where I already knew their relationship and couldn't help grinning most of the time :D

I also got to know Declan...shortly after reading about his death.  John is so gonna kick his ass.  That would be a very interesting scene to read. 

I'm also interested to know a little about the Celtic spoken in these stories.  What's its origin? Region? Eh, I'm an Australian with my roots lost in the mists of time, but I've always been interested in the early tribal cultures of Britain and Europe...and I am always curious.

I should also mention here that you are so very mean to Dean ::tickles you::  The poor bugger is lucky to survive your fics :D  Actually come to think of it, he actually died in this one.  You is truly of the evol.  (Says me who is far from innocent in that area myself in several fandoms :D)  Of course, this is one of the reasons why I read your fic.  You put them on the brink, where words that would not otherwise be said can be said.  I'm just a sucker for whump and you do it beautifully :D

And now I've run out of GaelicSpirit fic.  ::pouts::  I guess I'll have to go reread them now.

::wanders off looking for that printed copy of the New Orleans story::

Thanks so very much for writing and sharing.  There was muchly enjoyment.

Nutty
(who should go cook dinner...really...::doesn't::)



Author's Response:

Ach, Nutty I was so happy to get this review! I'm glad that you grinned while reading about Brenna in this one, knowing what you know from having read the others. To me that means the evolution of her character and her relationship to the boys (especially Dean) stayed true.

I toyed with the idea of writing an epilogue to this one with the Declan/John smack-down, but when I started writing, I had some... John issues. Mostly transferring my own parental issues onto the poor man, so I wrote him mostly as I saw him through Dean's eyes and through Sam's eyes. The closest I've ever come to actually writing John is in the epilogue to Ramble On. Maybe I'll try it again with a one-shot some day...

The Celtic is Irish Gaelic, mostly from Ulster. The pronounciation and spelling is slightly different between Ulster, Munster, and Connacht. Dublin is in Ulster, and that's where I lived for a bit while in college. Between my books from school, my notes, and the Internet (god bless it) I have been able to pull the Gaelic together for these stories.

You've got a point in the Dean-torture. I choose not to delve too deeply in why putting that lovely boy through the wringer is so appealing to me -- both in writing and reading -- but I think it's something about his strength, and his layers. He is such a wonderfully complex character that it seems almost impossible to get to the core of him unless he's against a wall, his will tested...

Plus, he's just so damn sexy.

Thanks so much for reading and taking time to review each story. :)

GS

 
Summary:

The New Orlean's job comes back to haunt Dean as he and Sam return to stop a series of murders, and end up discovering an evil they may not be able to defeat...with Dean's life in the balance.


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 59227
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 10/04/07 Title: Chapter 8: Chapter 8

I'm going to have to re-read this to give you some decent feedback. I think I picked it up on FF.net a few months back...I can't remember.  It was the second SN fic I had ever read and I remember thinking that it was extremely well written and had an excellent plot.  Everytime I see the pilot ep, I think of this fic.  You did a wonderful job and I'm sorry if I neglected to drop you a review.

I would re-read it now, but I'm entirely too distracted by the fact you have OTHER wonderful looking fics posted here and I am going eat them with my eyeballs first :D 

Thank you so much for writing.  Your story was thoroughly enjoyable.

Nutty
(of the absent mind)



Author's Response:

Nutty!! Hello there! Ta for the review, woman. And for letting me know you'll be checking out the other fics. Yay! I'm always open to feedback, whenever it appears. :)

And -- I just read one of your fics today! Funny, yeah? It was fabulous.

Hope to see you again soon.

Cheers -- GS

 

 
Summary:

banner created by Kira Reed

When a hunt goes sideways, the brothers are hurt and lost in the northern Minnesota woods. They have only each other and their skills to get them out...and they aren't alone. They are being tracked by the 'perfect hunter'.


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 9 Completed: Yes Word count: 67711
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 13/04/07 Title: Chapter 9: Epilogue

I absolutely adored this.  I printed it off and read it from one end to the other curled up on my couch, my eyes literally eating the words off the page.  It is on my list to reread and probably reread, reread and reread a little bit more :D

There were so many moments of perfect brotherly affection.  Both brothers' stubborn determination, the banter, the sacrifice....oh, I love the whole damn thing :D

The thing that sticks in my mind at the moment is Dean following that travois.  He'd do anything for Sammy.

Damnit, that fic is just perfect.  Thankyou so much for writing and posting.  You provided me with many enjoyable hours with many more to come:D

Nutty
(who can't say enough)



Author's Response:

It's you!! Hello Nutty one! Thank you so much for the review -- I appreciate it deeply. I'm grinning big time here.

I'm so glad you could curl up with this and read, reread, and reread again. For me, that's the true measure of a good story -- if I can and want to read them again. So THANK YOU for that. :)

I thank you for taking time to let me know your thoughts -- hope to see you 'round here again sometime.

GS

 
Summary: Dean is crashing after a string of bad jobs. One last, terrible incident pushes him over the edge. He’s on a downhill slide and the Moonstar is the last place he needs to be.
Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 19 Completed: Yes Word count: 50575
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 08/01/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 22/02/07 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2 Running on Empty

Wow, that was dark and painful.  Poor Dean.  It never really occurred to me that the boys would have jobs that didn't quite go right (though it should have...I'm just showing my newness to the fandom :D).  This is a chilling example.

Your writing is excellent and I got great pictures off it all, gory though they be :D  I'm eagerly jumping to the next chapter.

Nutty
(newbie) 



Author's Response: Well hi! Welcome to UnScripted Genius and welcome to my world! I'm glad you liked it, hope you enjoy the rest!

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 22/02/07 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3 Stained

There is no such thing as a boring chapter.  If it was boring the author would axe it and this is far from boring :D

Lots of brotherly stuff in this one :D Each brother looking after the other in his own way.  Typical Dean, though, sometimes that boy has to be tied down no matter how much he'd snarl.  Sam's certainly got his hands full.

I would eagerly jump to the next chapter but RL calls.  I will be back though.

Thanks for writing.

Nutty
(RL can be annoying)



Author's Response: I'm with you on the RL....

 
Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 24/02/07 Title: Chapter 19: Chapter 19

Okay, so I cracked, fixed up my printer that was connected to my poor sick computer and wrangled it to print this off for me so I could read it in bed.  It was sooo good!

I love the imagery of the town.  I wanna visit.

The plotline was excellent.  The whole story of Margaret (::insert shiver here::) and Stephen and the crazy doctor (die, you bastard, die!) and the finger.

Also the image of Dean curled in on himself in a dirty corner of that morgue...::bites lip::

Yours is only the fourth fic I've read since falling head first into this fandom sometime last week :D but it is one of the best.  Oh, um, your other fic 'Cry in the Night' was number 5 and shares the title :D 

Thanks for writing, thanks for the angst and I'm off to poke around here some more :D

Nutty
(who really needs to write some SPN fic of her own)



Author's Response:

I'll be honest I love Moonstar. One of my persanl faves. I'm so glad you liked it. It was strange to put a story in a setting i knew so well.

 Please write something! I'd love to read your stuff. This junk is addicting!

 
Summary:

Making a deal with a Demon can be an unseemly business. Especially when you discover that the deal you've made has endangered your sons in ways you hadn't foreseen. Now they've grown up apart and unaware and things need to be set right. General AU oddness.

 

Paved Banner


Categories: AU Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 9 Completed: Yes Word count: 44413
[Report This] Published: 10/01/07 Updated: 07/03/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 11/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Prologue

I was typically confused at the beginning of this cos I'm just so slow upstairs :D All I could chant in my head was 'No Dean! No Dean!', but this is Irismay!  There can't be 'No Dean'.  There must be Dean! :D

But as I read into the prologue and the AU you had created formed clearly in my head, the panic morphed into a subtle pain at the lack of Dean.  There is something just not right about Sam growing up without Dean!

I can see this is going to be an intriguing fic and I turn the page with eagerness and a painful squawking wail of 'What happened to Dean???'

Cos Dean without Sam hurts even more.

Great stuff :D  ::grins eagerly::

Nutty
(sense is not a requirement) 



Author's Response: Heh heh heh...  The likelihood of my writing a Dean-less story seems very remote somehow...  The bizarre thing is, I seem to keep writing Sam stories just lately!  You're quite right though, you really can't have one without another!

 
RECOIL by Tree66 Rated: T starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 14]
Summary:

He's silently and methodically cleaned those guns a million times over the years; but tonight, they speak to him.


Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 5116
[Report This] Published: 21/01/07 Updated: 21/01/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 11/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

::shivers::  Okay, that was downright chilling.  And there was some serious ouch towards the end.

I like how you set it all up and the visionesque of the ending just amplified the chill.

Ouch.

Thanks for writing.  That was great.

Nutty
(ouch)



Author's Response:

Thanks Gumnut and again- welcome to UnGen. I'm glad you liked that one! It was fun to write and chilled me a bit too!

 

 
Summary:

The brother's strengths are tested when they are confronted by both a supernatural threat... and a human one. Dean must face his fear of losing his brother in order to save not only Sam, but himself as well.


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 94133
[Report This] Published: 08/02/07 Updated: 28/03/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 16/04/07 Title: Chapter 8: Chapter 8

You continue to amaze me at your ability to write such extensive stories with the characters we all know and love so true to form.  It's almost like you cut down to the core of the brothers and play the strong emotional chords we all like to hear.

Brenna is also an interesting character, though I think I've stuffed up by reading the fics she is in incorrect order.  I'm fixing that now as we speak, the first story running through my printer in prep for some lovely nighttime reading :D  This is where I go back to where it all started.

I also have to say that you write some of the best Dean-collapse/faint scenes I've ever read.  That moment early on in this fic, just after the brawl, dean was begging for Sam to look at him...you orchestrated that perfectly for most emotional impact.

Did I mention I'm enjoying your fics?

You wouldn't happen to have a Live Journal floating around would you?  ::grin::  If not, perhaps I could persuade you to enter the world of blogging, cos I'd love to see your words on my friends page :D

Anyway, I'm babbling.  Thank you so much for writing such a long and enjoyable fic.  I look forward with eagerness to reading this next/first one, but I will be pining after that cos I will have run out.  (That's a not so subtle hint for you to write more, cos I'm greedy :D).

Thanks for sharing.

Nutty
(off the edge, but learning to fly)



Author's Response:

Aw, Nutty one, you do make me smile. I am so glad to see that you think I get to the core of these brothers. Thank you for that. And thanks, also, for letting me know that you're going back to where it all began. Remember, though, it's the first fanfic I'd ever written and I've learned a lot since then... :)

I don't have an LJ -- in fact, I'm ashamed to admit it, but I can't quite figure out that site. I tried once, took me all afternoon to figure out how to navigate (forget uploading a story!) and so I gave up. I've linked to some people's journals so that I can enjoy their work, but nothing out there for me.

And this world of blogging you speak of... what's that exactly? Feel free to email me if you want to babble *wink* more about it.

I am so glad you've enjoyed my fics -- and I do plan to write more. But I'm kind of a "focus on one fic at a time" gal, and I'm working on the VS story right now... I have 3 that I'll be writing on there, spread over the summer, so there will be time for me to post more stories. And I hope that when I do, I get a dose of Nuttiness. :)

Thanks for taking time with me. Spread your wings, girl.

GS

 
Summary:

This is a tag for Born Under a Bad Sign.  Driving, a few hours after the end of the episode.  My first fanfic.  I should mention I haven't actually seen the entire episode.  Let me know what you think....


Categories: General, One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 725
[Report This] Published: 15/03/07 Updated: 15/03/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 05/05/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Oooh, I really like this and that is one hell of a killer last line.  A nice little tag.

Thanks heaps for writing and sharing.

Nutty
(who should be writing, but is bludging instead)



Author's Response:

Thanks a lot for the review!  I live for feedback.  :)  I'm glad you liked it. 

 
Summary: Sam was awake for some of it; he just doesn't know how much. Tag for Born Under a Bad Sign.

Categories: One Shots, General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1736
[Report This] Published: 12/04/07 Updated: 12/04/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 21/04/07 Title: Chapter 1: The Devil You Know

Nicely written and powerful :D

 

I'd never considered the fact that Sam might have done other th8ngs while under the influence.  And you're right, there are many hours in a week.  Crap like that could really mess with your mind.  I wonder if Kripke and crew might pick up on those missing hours down the track. 

Excellent piece of work.  I thoroughly enjoyed that. Thanks for writing and sharing.

Nutty
(always a sucker for a good fic)

 
Fate by gaelicspirit Rated: T starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 26]
Summary: In the space between the life they have and the life they wish for, exists the life they are meant to lead. Dean's sacrifice as told through Sam's eyes...
Categories: General, One Shots, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 9246
[Report This] Published: 07/05/07 Updated: 07/05/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 08/05/07 Title: Chapter 1: As brothers

I love the snarky first line.  I love the scenes with fragile Dean that fills out bits I knew were missing from the ep.  I love Sam breaking the law to save his brother.

You've  demonstrated Dean's devastation so well.  The poor guy needs a hug and vacation  ::glares at Sam::  Let the poor guy have a vacation!  Can't you see he's falling apart at the seams???

But most of all I absolutely adore the last paragraph.

In between what life is, and what we wish life could be is where we find our purpose. If Dean could turn his back on a chance at having the only thing that he'd ever wanted - a family - then I can stand up to the Demon's plans. Not in front of my brother - he'd never allow that. And not behind him - although he will try to step in front of me. But next to him. I will stand beside him and we will face this storm together.

As brothers.

Oh, you said that soooo well.  ::huggles you::  I can just see Dean arguing with Sammy at that moment, then Sam putting his foot down.

Also, the instances of present tense writing seems to be rife in this fandom.  Usually I find that tense awkward to read, but for some reason it works perfectly for Supernatural and you worked it well.

Thanks so much for writing and sharing.  I so adore your stuff.

Nutty
(finally free of libraryOrk only to be faced with errandOrk  ::grrs::  Wanna write.)



Author's Response:

Nutty!! Thanks so much for the feedback -- you know how I crave it. I'm so glad that last paragraph spoke to you. And thanks for mentioning the 1st person POV. It was a first for me, and I'm really glad it came over okay in this. You know the writing adoration is mutual, so hopefully errands ease and you're able to write later.

Thanks again for reading and I hope to see you in other reviews soon!

GS

 
Masks by gaelicspirit Rated: T starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 15]
Summary: Dean knows the right lines to say and the right role to play for every moment... until the moments start to play him.

Categories: General, One Shots, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 5195
[Report This] Published: 07/05/07 Updated: 07/05/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 07/05/07 Title: Chapter 1: Protection

Ooooh, ouch, ouch, ouch...

But! GSfic!  ::bounces around madly::

Read this one before breakfast :D 

This is certainly a different take on the humour in that episode and looks at Dean's actions in the ep a way I hadn't considered before.

I repeat myself...ouch. 

I think you're right.  At the end of heart, both brothers' hearts were broken, if for slightly different reasons and you've illustrated Dean's side of the story really well here.

Also there is so much reason here why Dean lives his life as a lie.  And it doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the law. 

Excellent writing as usual and I am so envious on your word count  ::musses up your hair::  You've written 15,000 words since we last spoke!  And with your schedule!  ::is jealous of your abilities::

Thanks so much for writing and sharing.  I was so excited to see new fic from you....and I still have one to read  ::bounces::

Nutty
(off to find brekky and read fic)



Author's Response:

15,000 words?! Huh. Wow. Well, I was sick, and the hubby graciously offered to care for the bambino, and I couldn't hear the TV (ear infection), so I just wrote through my misery. And, what do you know. I'm better today. :)

Thanks so much for this feedback. ::Hugs Nutty:: I am so glad you took time to review. I wasn't sure about this one -- total off the top of my head, and only my 2nd tag. I'm glad you liked it.

Is there more Truth out there? Shall I go check?

Looking forward to seeing what you think of other fic...

GS 

 
Summary: Everything has a first time. John just thought he'd be able to protect Dean longer... This is the back story of Dean's connection to IRA villian Jack Collins in Into the Fire. One-shot.
Categories: General, One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 8589
[Report This] Published: 19/05/07 Updated: 19/05/07


Reviewer: Gumnut Signed
Date: 20/05/07 Title: Chapter 1: A Life Less Ordinary

Oh crap, I ran out of fic.  I was so lost in that, I didn't realise I was coming to the end.  Mmmm, GS fic :D  When's the next one?  ::puppy dog eyes::

You did some wonderful characterisation of young Dean and Sam.  Sam's innocence sang true through out the fic and in young dean I could so see the older Dean we know and love.

Incidently, Jack Collins is so dead...did he die in that other fic?  ::ponders::  Hmm, an excuse to go read it again, me thinks :D

I also loved your characterisation of John.  The loving father caught up in his obsession.  Where Dean and Sam are each others' weakness, the boys are John's and you illustrated that perfectly in this fic.

Did I mention that Jack Collins is a dead man?

I also liked how you kept Dean out of the worst of his father's occupation up to this point and how John had tried to protect his sons somewhat. A lot of writers forget that John loved his sons more than anything and while he made their lives difficult, he didn't neglect them as much as some would believe.

All in all, a lovely fic, but then I would never expect anything less from the Great GS.  Thanks so much for writing and sharing.  I loved it.

Nutty
(who takes advantage of her poor memory so she can reread fics all the time)



Author's Response:

*blushes*

You are too kind to me. Thanks so much for this review.

*blushes again*

Yep, Jack Collins met a violent and well-deserved end in Into the Fire. His obsession overtook him -- but not before he messed up our Dean a bit more. Damn him.

Thanks for saying the characterization of John worked for you. I usually shy away from writing him -- Ramble On was the only time I really tried. But I agree with you. He had his faults (as I'm learning...what parent doesn't?!), but he loved those boys.

Thanks for taking time to review. :)

GS