Supernaturalville
Penname: rahne [Contact]
Real name: linda l. wilson
Status: Member
Member Since: 14/09/08
Website:
Beta-reader:
Wasn't planning to do this, since at this point I'm not writing, only reading. Also, I do not use my E mail; I think it has brought down the writing, thinking ,spelling skills of almost everyone who uses it routinely. Punctuation seems to be a lost cause. (I'm not really as bitter as I sound, I just love literature and the English language in all it's richness, and I decry the fall in basic literacy in our society.) As you have probably guessed, I am in my fifties, (56), a graduate of U. of Michigan, and retired as an Emergency Room physician 6 years ago after 23 years of practice. I have always studied ancient history, myth, and religion as an avocation, and I absolutely love Supernatural. The ideas, the characters, the superb acting, all fascinate me. I only recently discovered supernatural fanfic, and have been devouring it rapidly. (And raptly.) I thought it might help a few authors to know who is writing them such long reviews. (I don't even know what the lines below mean, so not going to try and fill them out.) I would be a good beta reader, I think, but without email, how would you ask me? Besides, my computer hours are few, and intermittent. Maybe someday.
[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by rahne
 
Summary: Castiel's thoughts when he officially meets Sam Winchester. (tag to 4.07 "It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester.")
Categories: One Shots, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 607
[Report This] Published: 31/12/08 Updated: 01/01/09


Reviewer: rahne Signed
Date: 02/02/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Never thought of it this way. Like Sam, I thought Cass hesitated because he didn't want to touch someone bearing demon blood. Uriel certainly feels that way. He despises Ruby, even though he knows she is trying to help. (Not quite the same, I know, but still...) I guess I should have known that the "doubter" would be more "humane". I'm afraid I don't believe that Cass sought and recieved permission from God, however. Not the Old Testament god Kripke seems to be referencing in season 4. But maybe I'm underestimating Kripke, and he'll surprise me. After all, his version of god didn't kill Anna in her human persona, even though I find it hard to believe He couldn't find her. As Dean said, just because His Believers are dicks, doesn't mean He has to be. And it's pretty clear that Kripke (like me) believes the ideal state for conscious beings is Human, for all our flaws and weaknesses. Good fic, made me think. Thanks.

 
Summary: Sam realizes how dangerous his demon powers really are when they are used against a human.

[tag to 4.04 Metamorphosis]


Categories: AU, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1376
[Report This] Published: 31/12/08 Updated: 01/01/09


Reviewer: rahne Signed
Date: 02/02/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Sorry, can't buy this one. Sam can get angry and confused, but I can't see him so jealous of Castiel that he would try to kill him, or even attack him. Sam resented Dean's allegience to their Dad, but he was never jealous of him. And he really is still trying to use his powers only for good. He's not this far gone yet.

Author's Response:

hence the disclaimer AU. I think he's a little jealous of Dean's "heavenly" status while he's left with the demons. And who knows, maybe Sam will get close to being this dark in the future.

~A

 
Summary: Dean's need for salvation isn't just based on the fact that part of him enjoyed Hell. (Tag to S4 "Family Remains")
Categories: One Shots, Missing Scenes Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 794
[Report This] Published: 18/01/09 Updated: 19/01/09


Reviewer: rahne Signed
Date: 01/02/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

It's pretty obvious that this is just how Dean feels. Well written. I just wish Sam,(or even Castiel) could make him see that that darkness is in all of us, and that he should be proud of the fact that he just SURVIVED! Whole, and sane, and able to still feel guilt and pain and remorse. And Compassion. It was his darkness that made him strong enough to hold onto himself. (Just as I believe John did. Two men who had learned to be hard and unfeeling when they had to be, to save themselves and the world. ) Has Dean ever thought about what John had to do to survive for 100 years? Not before, certainly, but now? Now that he understands what really happened to his father? Would he hate his father for it, as he hates himself right now? Would he rather have been turned, become truly unfeeling as a Demon? I think not, despite the pain he lives with now. I hope he can finally learn, in time, to accept that he is just a man. A strong, good man. If he can't, I don't think he'll be ready to save his brother when Sam really needs him, at the end. And that is what he was born to do.

 
Reviewer: rahne Signed
Date: 01/02/09 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

P.S. Why is it so many of the writers in this fanfic can't seem to differentiate between CONSCIOUS and CONSCIENCE.? These words are not interchangeable! Sorry, but mixing up words is my major pet peeve. English is the richest language in the world. Use it! Say exactly what you mean, there is always a correct word. Thanks for letting me vent.