Supernaturalville
Penname: ciel4 [Contact]
Real name:
Status: Member
Member Since: 10/01/07
Website:
Beta-reader:

[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by ciel4
 
Summary: Post “FaithSam tries to helpDean come to terms with his guilt over Layla.
Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 3098
[Report This] Published: 30/12/06 Updated: 30/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 22/01/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This is fabulous - I love it when Sam kicks Dean's bed! Dean doesn't value himself nearly enough, and the way you have described it hits the nail right.on. the.head. I am trying to do more reviewing because I really appreciate the effort that goes into the stories, but I love your stuff and I want to encourage you to keep writing. This could be a not-so-subtle reminder to persevere with "Cry in the Night" - I'm still hanging on for the next chapter!

Author's Response: Ta. The reviews mean a lot to the writers, we appreciate the time ya'll take to touch base with us.Trying to get another chapter up by the weekend, might be the end or close to it.

 
Summary: Dean’s thoughts during the drive on the way to see Sam at Stanford.
Categories: One Shots Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 1165
[Report This] Published: 30/12/06 Updated: 30/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 10/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I think I have mentioned before that you write about vomiting very well! It's a talent. Of course, it's not the only thing you write well lol !!! The way you describe Dean's physical turmoil, brought on by his emotional turmoil, twists ME in knots. And I loved this line:

“Sammy…” he murmured to himself, “ready or not. here I come……”

And yes, it's beautiful!! 



Author's Response: Yeah, i think my position as puke queen is solid. I don't know why i get hung up on that, of all the damned things to have a fetish for. Not the act itself but the buildup to it. God, I am so weird....

 
Summary: Why they're always one night stands…Dean POV.
Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Completed: Yes Word count: 342
[Report This] Published: 30/12/06 Updated: 30/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 14/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

See, I never wanted to get to this point - reviewing my last Terry story here for the time being. That's why I kept leaving it unreviewed! But the time has come, so here goes. This is short but very sweet, and definitely tasteful. Pooor Dean. I like the idea that his one night stands are not just an outlet, but a substitute for someone he really loves but can't have. *Sigh*

Author's Response:

I didn't realize I hadn't responded to this. So sorry.

 Are you following the VS? Cause if you're not you're mising something!

 
Summary:

Following John's coordinates, the boys prepare to battle a witch. When they discover a greater evil is at work, can Sam save Dean's life or will his brother's pain become his own?


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 53269
[Report This] Published: 30/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 24/01/07 Title: Chapter 1: Coordinates

Hey GS, I know I did a general review for all 3 storiesof your stories when I finished Ramble On, but that was because I was in a hurry! I have re-read your stories since, and just wanted to write a specific review for each one because I really feel they deserve it. Hope you don't mind. 

Some authors get the action in a Supernatural fic right, and some get the brothers' relationship right, but you do both. Brenna is wonderfully written: she is a likeable stand-alone character,and she doesn't threaten Dean and Sam's relationship. If she had,I would have been mightily tempted to hate her! Dean is a big damn hero, and he is "magnificent" in your story - I love that Sam sees that. Thanks for the effort that goes into such a tale.



Author's Response:

Mind?! Are you kidding? You just made my day!

I'm so happy to hear that you've actually re-read my stories! I'm a mult-time reader myself of those stories I truly enjoy (published or otherwise) and so to know that someone did that of mine makes me grin so big I look like I slept with a hanger in my mouth. ;)

I thank you for your kind words and your specificity of what you liked. Telling stories is my passion, and my fulfillment comes from seeing that they resonate for the reader.

Thanks again -- GS

 
Summary:

The New Orlean's job comes back to haunt Dean as he and Sam return to stop a series of murders, and end up discovering an evil they may not be able to defeat...with Dean's life in the balance.


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 59227
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 24/01/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I loved this story on lots of levels but particularly because Sam gets fed up with people blaming Dean and he disputes the point, and he perceives a physical threat to Dean form other people and he muscles up to defend him. I would love to see those things on the show! I also love that the pre-story to this event happened while Dean and Sam were apart - Sam has a lot to learn about that time in Dean's life. And amazingly, even though you have written a more romantic session for Dean and Brenna, I still like her! Quite a feat! Fantastic work.Thank you!

Author's Response:

Again, thank you so much for this!

Just once I'd love to see Sam take care of Dean, protect Dean, somehow even maybe defend him on the show. I know Dean's older, the protector, the defendor of Sammy -- but in families it should be reciprocated (sometimes...IMO).

I was nervous about that interlude with Dean and Brenna. But it was the 2nd time I'd brought them together, and they were attracted to each other... and it's DEAN... so I had to go for it, knowing that she wasn't going to stay.

But, um, she's coming back, so hopefully the fact that you like her will have you reading another story with her in it. She won't be in them all... but she's fun to write. She's an escape from me. And I'll shut up now.

Cheers -- GS

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 26/01/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Just once I'd love to see Sam take care of Dean, protect him, maybe even defend him on the show. GS

Yes,yes,yes - exactly! That's why I love your writing so much - because Sam stood up to the Coulees for Dean, tried to take revenge on the banshee for Dean and struggled to get to him in the hospital after the wendigo attack. See? You are answering a serious need here. And now, I'll shut up!

Thanks again,

 Ciel

 
Summary:

banner created by Kira Reed

When a hunt goes sideways, the brothers are hurt and lost in the northern Minnesota woods. They have only each other and their skills to get them out...and they aren't alone. They are being tracked by the 'perfect hunter'.


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 9 Completed: Yes Word count: 67711
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 31/12/06


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 10/01/07 Title: Chapter 9: Epilogue

This is my first ever review! By the time I had discovered this website, you had 3 completed stories up, and so this is really a review of all 3. Congratulations! I was enthralled. It is the bond between the brothers that appeals to me in the show, and you have captured it beautifully. Of course, you have developed this theme beyond where the show would probably go, but as far as I am concerned you could not go too far!  Dean's heroism in the show is a little underrated too, but I feel that you portray it wonderfully through Sam's growing understanding of his brother. I also admire your drawing of the characters of Brenna and Abe. For me they reflect your audience's admiration (well, mine at least!) for Dean and Sam. I hope you have another story in the pipeline, because I am longing for more!

My compliments,

Ciel



Author's Response:

Wow. Thank you. I really appreciate your review and especially the kudos on Brenna and Abe. Including an OFC is usually chancy in this fandom, but I really wanted a way to show a part of Dean -- inside him, if you will -- that he wouldn't willingly show us himself. And thus, Brenna appeared.

I so love these brother's and their bond, so thanks for saying that for you I did them justice. I have some more up my sleeve, but have been writing for a different medium for a bit. I'll have another to post in a few weeks.

Hope to see you then!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 24/01/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

And now for my favourite of all your stories! I adore the little details - the Riddick reference, Dean drawing the protection symbol on the travois, Dean thinking Abe was his dad and Sam playing along, the flashbacks (especially the first hunt after Sam left, when Dean went through the motions without saying a single word). Sick/hurt Dean twists my guts, (and like you I avoid analysing why!) so this story had me absolutely in knots. You will have to unravel me by writing another story - my humble and ill-disguised effort to encourage you gently towards your next   Supernatural fiction! Which brings me to another point.I realise I have been incredibly fortunate to have arrived late to this site, because all of your stories were complete and I could read them straight through. How will I cope when you are posting a chapter at a time????? This story is a masterpiece, but I'm sure you can match it - thanks again!

Author's Response:

This is my favorite, too. OC's are fun to create and write, but nothing beats our boys together.

Ciel, you've completely turned my day around with these individual reviews of my three stories. Thank you so much for taking the time!

So, I hope I don't jinx myself by saying this, but when I'm writing and posting, it's usually pretty quick. None of my stories have been over 8 chapters (though some chapters are longer than others) and from beginning to end, it's about a four-week time period. It's only because I can't hold it in. When the story starts to come alive past the "idea" stage in me, if I don't tell someone (i.e. post it) it drives me nuts!

Hopefully that will be the way of it in the future -- and I dearly hope to see you on a review page then.

Take care of you -- GS

 
Summary: Dean is crashing after a string of bad jobs. One last, terrible incident pushes him over the edge. He’s on a downhill slide and the Moonstar is the last place he needs to be.
Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 19 Completed: Yes Word count: 50575
[Report This] Published: 31/12/06 Updated: 08/01/07


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 14/03/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1 Teaser

I have just finished reading Moonstar again, and although I think I have referred to a couple of things in this story in passing during other reviews, it really deserves its own comments on its own review page! You did an awesome job describing Dean's state of mind and the way he blames himself for everything that goes wrong. That stuff can really eat away at you, as it does to Dean. And although I am hopelessly Dean-centred I loved Sam in this one - especially the take-charge tone he adopted when he informed Dean of their program after this hunt  - nothing but sleeping and eating until Sam said otherwise! Fantastic.

And it goes without saying (but I'm saying it) that the fight on the roof was just awesome, and the spiritual cleansing in the rain was very.... spiritual. What an image.

Thanks Terry!

 

 
Summary: A shortcut through the woods leaves the boys lost, seperated and hunted. 
Categories: General, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Shadow Stalker
Chapters: 16 Completed: Yes Word count: 46418
[Report This] Published: 01/01/07 Updated: 07/01/07


Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Hi Devonshire, I'm enjoying "In Transit" so much I thought I would try and catch up with some of your other work ....although lord knows I have enough trouble keeping up with the "Most Recents"!  This is a great start, love the dialogue between the brothers, it sounds just like them. But I have to say that I think Dean stalking off into the night alone is probably a bad move. Maybe very bad? I guess I'll soon see!

Author's Response: i'm glad you are enjoying the stories. that you so much for the reviews. and yes, dean stalking off alone was a very, very bad idea. 

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2

I kind of like the idea of John having the boys followed. In the normal world that would be kind of stalkerish - but they don't live in a normal world!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Wow, very spooky, almost Twilight Zone" feel about it. I love it! It's nice to hear Sam say he won't leave without Dean. Atta boy!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 4

I had a bad feeling  about Joshua! Tthe traitor!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 5: Chapter 5

Poor Dean! The emotional pain is worse than the physical pain in my opinion - and I think they are both going to get him into massive trouble!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6

Just in the nick of time John! Hope they find Dean soon, that 26 hours WOULD have been brutal!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7

I've gotta say, it serves Joshua right!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 8: Chapter 8

Oh, they're so close to him! Come on John and Sam......Dean's right there. Obviously I am getting too involved in this story!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 9: Chapter 9

At last they found him. I'm really enjoying this devonshire, they're not out of the woods yet - physically or emotionally!


Author's Response: i am so glad you are enjoying it, ciel. and no, they arent out of the wood by any means, not even close. **evil laugh**

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 25/06/07 Title: Chapter 10: Chapter 10

Love the banter - it's such an identifying feature of their relationship, and one of the reasons we love them so! But it's not always easy to do. Well done Devonshire!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 26/06/07 Title: Chapter 11: Chapter 11

Liked the insight into John blaming himself for Mary's death, the way Sam did for Jess. And that Dean knew that those ideas weren't right. Very perceptive!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 26/06/07 Title: Chapter 12: Chapter 12

Loved this line:

The thing went into an evil monologue. What else would the bad guy do?”  LOL

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 26/06/07 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 13

I have decided I hate Joshua. Evil cliffhanger devonshire, and I can't read more now until tomorrow! But I'll be back then...can't wait.

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 28/06/07 Title: Chapter 14: Chapter 14

Hey good thinking, I'd forgotten about the amulet! And poor Dean, his feelings about his family - and his ideas about their feelings towards him - are just so painful!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 28/06/07 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 15

Awesome action, and great timing too!

 
Reviewer: ciel4 Signed
Date: 28/06/07 Title: Chapter 16: Chapter 16

Terrific ending, I really enjoyed the whole story. Thanks so much!


Author's Response: thank you so much for all the great reviews, i am glad you enjoyed the story.