Supernaturalville
Penname: Huntergal [Contact]
Real name: Connie
Status: Member
Member Since: 22/06/07
Website:
Beta-reader:

[Report This]
 
 
Reviews by Huntergal
 
Summary: Past Featured Story

Dean, Sam and Valkyrie

Valkyrie, Dean and Sam (Banner by Tru_Faith_Lost) 

 

Souls sometimes travel the same path together.  Who protects the protector?

Sam is snatched by a serial killer who finds out justice according to Dean Winchester doesn't involve a court room.


Categories: General, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Two Souls
Chapters: 15 Completed: Yes Word count: 56075
[Report This] Published: 08/02/07 Updated: 29/03/07


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 23/06/07 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 14/Epilogue

I didn't stop to review this completed story along the way, but wanted to tell you how much I enjoyed it. Very well written; pulled me in right away and kept me on the edge of my seat. Great action and superb emotional trauma. Just loved the wonderful brotherly contact and bond you portrayed. Our boys just can't be apart - especially under those circumstances! The killer was a real whacko - you wrote him very well - made him as scary as anything supernatural.

I've just found this site, but will certainly be coming back for more amazing work like this. Thanks for sharing your talents with us.



Author's Response:

Thanks so much.  I'm glad you enjoyed it.  A Safe, Secure Place is in progress and is the sequel.

Laura

 
Gale Warnings by bayre Rated: T starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 165]
Summary:

  

banner by Neolani618

Sam has a mysterious teacher who considers hunting a type of homework. A revelation may cause one brother to lose the other in order to keep him.  The brothers learn exactly how much they mean to one another, how deeply their bond runs and what one will do for the other. 

All things supernatural don't have to be evil.  Dean and Sam get a look at the 'bigger picture.' 

 


Categories: General, Action, Misc Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: The Elements
Chapters: 15 Completed: Yes Word count: 56757
[Report This] Published: 08/04/07 Updated: 10/06/07


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 06/09/07 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 15

I just finished this wonderful story. Fabulous! I loved your accurate portrayal of both brothers, their interactions, banter and caring for one another. I also got a kick out of Craven - what an interesting character. I loved the way he gave John a piece of his mind - something we all would have enjoyed after what he did to Dean with that secret.

There was brotherly angst aplenty and humor as well. Dean with the troll - need I say more? The story flowed wonderfully and I look forward to the sequel. Thanks for sharing this amazing fic with us. Until next time...



Author's Response:

Thanks so much.  Yeah, Dean..a troll...it's one of my favorite parts.

Laura

 
Summary:

The only way to get Dean is through Sam. The only way to hurt Sam is with Dean…..Two souls bonded together. Without one there truly is not the other….

The sequel to Bonding of Souls.

 

banner by neolani618


Categories: General, Action Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: Two Souls
Chapters: 14 Completed: Yes Word count: 48353
[Report This] Published: 13/06/07 Updated: 27/08/07


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 28/06/07 Title: Chapter 5: Chapter 5

After reading your fabulous "Bonding of Souls", I'm back to see what else you can do to our poor boys :) And you don't disappoint! My Lord, what they are going through - attacking and killing each other, watching each other tortured, killed, Dean almost drowning, Sam scared to death at losing Dean. Whew! Poor Sam, constantly repeating:"You were grey. You weren't breathing" to Dean. He has a point, the other tortures were only illusions, the near drowning was real.

And now Sam's having a vision - somehow I don't think this bodes well for our boys. Can't wait to see where you're going with this awesome fic. Love your writing style - the action, dialogue, emotions, fears - all so real. Looking forward to the update.



Author's Response:

Wow, thanks so much, your comments are very much appreciated.  Thanks for reading.

 

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 06/07/07 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6

Man, that vision thing is seriously screwing with Sam. Such an awful vision - and result. Now Dean's put in the position of having to shoot Sam to save the people on the train. Ack! I'm sure that Dean aimed carefully. Hope the boys can solve the mystery in time...

Author's Response: Thanks so much for reading and commenting.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 06/07/07 Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7

Interesting. Trying to figure out what Dean's doing, what he hopes to accomplish. Great action in this chapter. Glad Dean didn't have to shoot Sam :)  Loved that even when Sam was totally out of it, he still responded to Dean's command on instinct. Great job. Looking forward to the updates.

Author's Response:

Thanks for reading and for the reviews....I think all your questions should be answered by the end.

 

Laura

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 22/07/07 Title: Chapter 9: Chapter 9

Great chapter. Our poor boys, really broken. I liked how you portrayed Bobby - the way he watches Sam and Dean, sees their "innate communication", sees how in tune they are to one another. Oh gah, when Sam asked if he was going to wake up!  Duh - did he think his brother was going to kill him? Is he that out of it?

Hoping things go well with Dean's mission - somehow I don't think they will. Looking forward to see how this plays out.



Author's Response:

Thanks so much for reading and reviewing.

No won't be simple for Dean.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 02/08/07 Title: Chapter 10: Chapter 10

You sure like to play with Dean's head, girl. :) Really enjoyed Dean's emotional flip-flop in this chapter. He just didn't know what to believe. Why is it that I have this sick feeling that if this demon/spirit can manifest itself so "humanly" as Sam, it may also show up as Dean at Bobby's?  Can't wait for the update.

Author's Response:

There'll be a few challenges for all three of them coming up...thanks for reading and commenting.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 13/08/07 Title: Chapter 12: Chapter 12

Oh Jesus, girl! How can you do this to us? The visual at the end of this chapter was horrific...and extremely well done. Sam with the torch, Dean crashing outside to stop him...whew!

Reviewing Ch 11 & 12 here. Just loved the scene at Bobby's with the spirit impersonating Dean - afraid that was going to happen. At least Bobby and Sam knew the difference. Yeah, can't imagine anything scarier than Dean Winchester possessed. And Dean coming in and shooting himself (shades of "Skin"). Dean shooting Dean = hot! ;)

Fabulous story! I feel so sorry for both of the boys - they are going through hell. Hope that this ritual goes better than what's happened up to now. Looking forward to the update.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 27/08/07 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 13

Whoa! Was that a helluva chapter. My heart was in my throat while seeing the fire, Dean and Bobby trying to save Sam, the heroic rescue, the emotions of both brothers clinging to one another - whew! Our poor boys.

Then you throw them into a battle with the ghosts/demon in the house with flying debris. Can't get over all the fabulous action in this chapter. Great job.

Let's hope this ritual works and frees them from this horror. Looking forward to the update...



Author's Response: Thanks for reading, and for commenting.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 28/08/07 Title: Chapter 14: Chapter 14

A very satisfying end to a fantastic story. Both of the boys are healing, trying to balance their need to watch out/protect each other and the need to let the other have space to become naturally independent again. Spending some casual down-time, enjoying "normal".

What a horrific ordeal they survived in this tale. It's a wonder they are in one piece. Really enjoyed the writing in this - a great balance of intense action and emotion.

Thanks for sharing this amazing fic with us. I look forward to reading more of your work. Until next time...



Author's Response:

Thanks so much. I'm thrilled to know you liked the ending, it's the hardest part I think to write.

Laura

 
What You Feel by bayre Rated: K+ starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 279]
Summary: Past Featured Story

 

 banner by tru_faith_lost

 

 

Sam picks up on the feelings of everyone around him and Dean has...other issues. 


Categories: General, Action, Humor, Misc Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 13 Completed: Yes Word count: 49812
[Report This] Published: 10/07/07 Updated: 14/10/07


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 07/09/07 Title: Chapter 9: It is better to be a lion for a day than a sheep for all your life

This is a great story - so completely original and different. Dean as a dragon and cougar and ??? Just loving it. Too bad they couldn't save the junkie - Dean did the best he could as "Puff". Love the interaction of the boys (?) or should I say Sam and whatever. Great "arrangement" that Sam made - no matter how difficult this is, it beats the alternative. Looking forward to the update on this one.

Author's Response: Thanks so much!

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 10/10/07 Title: Chapter 10: A dog is the only thing on earth that loves you more than he loves himself

Great chapter - I like Dean as a dog - somehow that fits ;) Didn't like how Sam couldn't control his anger that he got from that psycho druggie/dealer. The pink collar and leash - priceless. My only dog was named Tinkerbell, but she was a girl... Laughed out loud at the PMS line...oh Dean I love your quips.

Looking forward to the boys waking up from surgery. Hope Dean doesn't change while he's at the vet's.



Author's Response:

Dean didn't like that happening to Sam either.

Thanks for reading.

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 10/10/07 Title: Chapter 11: Things that upset a terrier may pass virtually unnoticed by a Great Dane

Great action on the road. Yeah, Sam needs to learn how to take advantage of the Impala's power. Don't like the situation they're in now - these guys just don't give up.

Great writing. Still loving the brothers' interaction even if it's animal to man. Only two more days of this nonsense, huh?



Author's Response:

Yep, just a few more days to go!

Thanks for reading....Laura

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 11/10/07 Title: Chapter 12: Wanted...Accepted...Home...Safe...

Nice chapter - loved the little speech Sam gave to the boy's sister. No, Dean would never, ever give up on Sam, and vice versa. So, Dean's back to himself? I thought that they had a day or so left of the deal. 

Looking forward to the conclusion and some more wonderful brotherly moments. "Wanted, accepted, home, safe" - that's what they are together, all right. 



Author's Response:

Glad you liked, thanks for reading.

 

 

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 21/10/07 Title: Chapter 13: Not a hunt…More like a chance encounter…

Wonderful story and a very nice finish. Loved that Dean was able to kill the trickster that hurt Sam using a "technicality". I enjoyed the admission from Sam that he had no idea what it was like to have no one love him, to be scared and feel alone.

Great interactions between the brother throughout the story. Thanks for sharing this with us.



Author's Response: Thanks!

 
Empath by ciel4 Rated: T starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 201]
Summary: Past Featured StoryIt was just a little scar on Dean's shoulder. But it was about to turn Sam's whole world upside down.

Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 7 Completed: Yes Word count: 15565
[Report This] Published: 16/07/07 Updated: 02/08/07


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 27/08/07 Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7 Empath

I didn't stop to review along the way, but wanted to tell you how much I enjoyed this story. Love the way you have written Dean, Sam and our lovable Bobby. Very true to character with excellent dialogue/emotions/thoughts. All of their interactions were spot on.

I like your writing style very much - nice combination of action and emotion. The story flowed beautifully and certainly kept me wanting more at the end of each chapter. Loved the ending - the quiet scene of the boys taking in a sunset together by the "lake". And Sam's determination to try to give Dean back the love and protection that Dean has always given him. Wonderful.

Thanks for sharing this amazing story with us. I'm off to check out more of your work. Until next time...



Author's Response: Thanks for leaving such a detailed and generous review Huntergal! I'm glad you enjoyed the story.

 
Summary:

Still reeling from the revelation of Dean's deal and Sam's resurrection, the brothers hunt down the Hell Gate demons. But one hunt sends them to a place where secrets kill, sins are punished, and Sam and Dean feel the impact of an ageless war. Co-written by Gaelicspirit and Sojourner84.

Banner by Sojourner84

As a thank you, Sojourner has created a vid for this story, set to Breaking Benjamin's "Evil Angel." We truly hope you enjoy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZYyRK77dPk


Categories: General Characters: None
Challenges:
Series: None
Chapters: 8 Completed: Yes Word count: 121283
[Report This] Published: 09/08/07 Updated: 18/01/08


Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 13/08/07 Title: Chapter 1: Monday: Pride

Great start! Threw us right into the action feet first again :)  And some action it is - Dean is getting pounded to smitereens. Just LOVE Hurt!Dean and all his snarky comments that make things worse for him. I feel a bit sorry for Sam who blames himself for all the loose demons, thinking that if he had killed Jake sooner, none of this (or his brother's deal) would have happened. That's a lot of baggage. Poor Sam.

The hunt intrigues me. It's Monday and there is a killing and a message about pride. Methinks we're dealing with the seven deadly sins here, so all hell is gonna break loose, isn't it? :)  Culminating with Sunday perhaps...

The boys' banter is so much fun to read. Their conversations are so spot on. Just loving the story. It's going to be another helluva ride, I'm sure. Looking forward to where you ladies are taking it. Until next time...



Author's Response:

Glee! It's you! So happy to see you here. Thanks for reading and for the review.

I enjoy reading action-packed beginings (and watching them in the movies, too) so it feels write when stories I'm working on begin that way... then they can back off a bit for perspective before WHAMO! The action grabs you once more.

At least... that's our plan. ;)

And you're right -- Sam's carrying around a lot of weight right now, and it's only going to get heavier...

You're onto something there, sister, with your musings about the hunt. Hopefully you'll hang with us until the end 'cause if we do it right, Sunday will certainly be bloody...

Thanks for the kudos on the dialog and banter. :) We "heard" it while writing, so it's gratifying to know it worked for you, too.

Slainte,

GS and SJ

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 18/08/07 Title: Chapter 2: Tuesday: Greed

Another engrossing chapter. Two gratuitous shower scenes -  very nice and thank you. Interesting take on nightmares - Sam isn't having them and Dean is. No surprise there - who wouldn't be having nightmares in his precarious situation? Eleven months - gah!

Enjoyed the banter about Dean's night out. He couldn't even remember her name... Oh, Dean.

The hunt has turned out to be what I thought it was. Being one of those "girls with the Catholic uniform skirts and knee-high socks" (in days long past) that Dean was mmming about, it wasn't that hard for me to figure out. I also think I know what the next sin they will encounter is from the clue. We'll see.

Glad to see that Sam is on the top of his game. Dean's heart just isn't in this hunt. Don't know whether that's important or not. And how about that maintenance guy? Mmm...

Great story/mystery here.  Enjoying the suspense, trying hard to figure it out and how it's going to affect our boys. So far they haven't been in too much peril on the hunt, but I know better than to think that will continue. Looking forward to seeing how this plays out. Until next time...



Author's Response:

Irish, you are the best. I love how descerning you are in your reading, and in your reviews. I swear you miss *nothing*. *Grins big.*

We had to spread out the shower scene love, yeah? Two writers, two boys... twice the magic. Hee.

And I don't know where the show will go, but in our heads, Dean would try to soak up as much of the things he enjoys doing -- including frisky women -- as he can in this his last year. Possibly. Glad you liked that.

So, since the hunt is what you had thought, my hope NOW is that you enjoy seeing them discover the clues and the ties that bind the clues together... as the week progresses, they'll have more and more to deal with and I very much look forward to your reactions. :)

Slainte,

GS (and SJ)

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 29/08/07 Title: Chapter 3: Wednesday: Gluttony

Wow, what a fabulously long chapter - I almost went through a bottle of wine reading it ;) Oh, and chocolate! Well, I guess you know what sin I'm guilty of now. Speaking of sins, I read some of the reviews/replies and laughed out loud when you said that Dean could be guilty of just about all of them - so true, so true - except the next one. Dean never is still, much less lazy.

Wonderful chapter! I loved the tone, the feel of this one. The opening that dealt with the loss that both boys are feeling; the devastating nightmares that they both are having because of Sam's death and the deal Dean made. What horrible fears lie beneath their facades - Sam's fear for Dean's life and that he came back "wrong"; Dean's fear of burning in hell and how he's failed everyone he loves and how disappointed they are in him. Loved this line: "Dean's eyes were shadowed, secret, normal" Oh, our poor, poor Dean.

I really enjoyed the hunt in this chapter as well - the boys separately putting clues together to figure out the next victim and what to look for next. What a horrific scene in that greenhouse - unfortunately, felt as if I were there. The humor to break the angst: "Been There, Drunk That"; "Freak-Takes one to know one"; "You couldn't take the heat, kid". Just loved it.

So on to sloth, if the boys are right. Problem is that they're getting there with too little, too late. Loved the last lines in the chapter - Dean is taking this personally. Speaking of personally, whatever it is that you've done differently in this chapter, has made it my favorite so far. Three down, four to go. Just lovin' it. Until next time... 



Author's Response:

*grin*

I love the last bit of your review. We really haven't done anything *differently* exactly... I think we're just getting into the rhythm of writing together. We have the story completely outlined and one might think it an easy task to then simply bring the story to life, but as we've discovered, it's a whole balancing act of time, beats, and styles.

Kinda like... playing jazz with words.

In any case, I'm glad that you've enjoyed this and hope to see more of you because it's only going to get darker from here.

OH! And as far as Dean being guilty of just about each of the seven deadly sins -- I couldn't agree with you more. Sloth is decidedly *not* one I'd pin on our boy. Although... there are times when sitting on a bed eating cheese fries and watching TV appeals to him. *wink*

And I have to say I laughed when you said you almost went through a bottle of wine while reading. Because I can't write until the baby is asleep, I often find myself doing so with a glass of wine nearby. As we were working on this last part, I kept shooting furtive glances at said glass and wondering if I should go exchange it for some water...

But I didn't.

Looking forward to seeing you again, Irish.

Slainte,

GS and SJ

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 12/09/07 Title: Chapter 4: Thursday: Sloth

Another fabulously long chapter. ( I finished the bottle of wine and started another - gluttony be damned! *wink*) I just loved the pace in the chapter opening. Sam is startled from his sleep, then rushing around to find a "shadow" and Dean. When Dean arrives, your description goes to a whole new level. Dean's heart is racing, fingers twitching; he's pacing the room like a caged animal while images from his nightmares flood his mind. Constant motion - the antithesis of sloth. Bravo!

I've got to tell you, the whole SamnDean conversation about the deal and its consequences really tugged at my heartstrings. Damned if you do; damned if you don't. The boys' anger was papable - each fearing for the other's sanity and loss. Dean's reminscence about when he came back after the deal and saw Sam alive and "standing". Gah! Oh Dean, you break me so.

Just love the way you ladies are weaving these clues into the story. The lazy worker at the winery stamped on the cork...and was Fr. Simons' nephew? Love it. And the little interaction with the maintenence guy (who now thinks they're gay) hmmm.... Yeah, I think we all need Columbo here - I'll grab my raincoat...

So on to Lust - appropriate for a Friday night :) Originally I thought that lust might be the last sin, but now I think I know which one it will be - I'll let you know. Just loving this complex, emotional roller-coaster ride. Your portrayal of the boys is phenomenal - Sam is driven and Dean's on the edge. Look out, Inferno. Can't wait to see them in action at the club. Until next time...



Author's Response:

*waves*

Thanks so much for reading, Irish -- and for this review. Gluttony be damned is right! I'm usually writing at really odd hours and can basically justify the obligatory glass of red by the "it's five o'clock somewhere"...

Thanks for pointing out the scenes that really struck you -- we both dug deep for this one and are glad that it shows. But that look on Dean's face in AHBL2 when he returns and saw Sam alive and standing... I can't get it out of my head and it sneaks into different scenes...

And for whatever reason, the times when they're asked for um, y'know -- King or two Queens has always gotten a laugh out of me, so there you go. :)

The Columbo quip was all SJ -- clever girl that she is. Thanks again for reading and can't wait to see you on "Friday"...

Slainte,

GS and SJ

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 01/10/07 Title: Chapter 5: Friday: Lust

God, this was The.Best.Chapter. The beginning just tore me in two - Dean's nightmares/memories of everything he's been through - his dad's death,  the secret, Sammy's death, his deal, his fear - it's a miracle he's survived at all. I felt physically exhausted and emotionally drained just reliving it all. And poor Sam, ensconced in guilt and worry over Dean, over this hunt, trying to set aside his own fears to help Dean. Oh, boys. You have simply broken my heart here.

The scenes at the Inferno were fantastic. Sam is reluctant to relax, even for a moment, and Dean is taking it all in with his usual Winchester style. But that description of Dean on the dance floor? All I have to say is if people are being punished by flames for lust, I better run for the hills! Whew! Hothothot! (pun intended) God, what are you trying to do to us? It's been nearly three months since we've seen any new scenes of Dean ;)

After I managed to cool down from the dance floor scene, you throw me into that horrific inferno in the abandoned apartment! God, this man/demon/winged whatever is truly sick. Sam's inner turmoil regarding the rapist, the girl's rescue, Dean nearly falling through the floor - literally looking down at the hellfire that awaits him, the harrowing escape from the collasping fire escape - WOW. That was some of the best, riveting action I've read. The fear for the boys' safety was palpable. Kudos to both of you for this amazing chapter. It was one helluva Friday night for our boys. If we thought they were wrecked before, I can't imagine how they're going to come back from this.

So, no new clues until next time. Sure am curious about what Dean saw - honestly have no idea about that. BTW, cool shout out to Top Gun with a slight twist to that great line from Meg Ryan. Eat your heart out, Maverick, Dean Winchester is the MAN. ;)

Can't wait until the next chapter and Saturday's sin. Hey, at least they saved one girl. Just loving this story with all its action, emotion, and complexities. You ladies rock. Until next time...



Author's Response:

YES! ::shoves fist into the air:: Can I just say I laughed out LOUD when I read that you got the Meg Ryan line. :) That's awesome!! You crack me up. I'm so glad you're back from vacation. Hee.

And yes -- they did save a victim this time. Thanks for pointing that out. The true victim, really.

We're both so glad you enjoyed this chapter -- I read your whole review with a grin so big I looked like I slept with a hanger in my mouth ::wink:: -- thanks for letting us know what parts got to you, and how they made you feel. That means a lot!

Nope... no clue this time, but just wait. Saturday is gonna be a whopper. That is, if we do it right... *hides*

Thanks for reading and taking time to review!!

Slainte,

Gaelic (and SJ)

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 27/10/07 Title: Chapter 6: Saturday: Envy

Another amazing (and lusciously long) chapter. These boys are beat to hell - emotionally and physically. Their pain, anguish, and anger are so pervasive throughout the chapter, it enveloped my soul. My heart really went out to Sam in this. Watching him lose his faith and fall into hopelessness was practically more than I could bear. It scared Dean too, because he knows that Sam needs that to carry on without him. Dean's thought that he was going to lose Sam even before he lost his own soul - Broke.My.Heart. Oh, boys... I loved all of the religious/philosophical discussion of angels, good and evil, faith and the choices we make. Nicely done.

So a fallen angel - didn't see that coming. But the maintenance man Bob turns out to be the angel - yes! I knew he was involved somehow. *I'm sure he doesn't look as good as Nic Cage ;)* But man, his power is phenomenal. He threw those boys around the barn like rag dolls and beat them even more to hell. Although Dean managed to get rid of him temporarily, they have a powerful adversary to confront and banish/kill tomorrow.

The victim of envy has been lost as well :(. Wrath is Sunday's sin - I suspected that it would be the last. But I noticed how our boys' wrath was growing constantly in this chapter. Methinks that is not going to bode well for our heroes. They really may need "a little interference" from above ;).

Loved all of the brotherly discussions and caring moments in this chapter. Can never get enough of that, especially when its written so well. You ladies are doing a spectacular job with this story. Congrats to Sojourner on her upcoming nuptials. I'm really looking forward to that bloody, bloody Sunday. Although I have to admit, I fear it as well. Until next time...



Author's Response:

So one trick SJ and I both do (which was cool because it made it easier to blend styles) is pick out an actor to "play" OCs. Bob is "played" by Paul Bettany. So, depends on what you think about good ol' Paul if he's as good looking as Nic Cage. :)

I'm glad you didn't see the fallen angel coming - but I knew you knew something hinky was up with Bob. We really hope you enjoy Sunday's chapter... faith cannot be lost forever or there would be no hope and neither SJ or I are the hopeless sort...

Thanks so much for reading, for sticking with us, and for this review.

Gaelic (and SJ)

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 06/12/07 Title: Chapter 7: Sunday: Wrath

Wow, just wow. To quote Demon!John in “Devil’s Trap”, now this was worth waiting for – what a spectacular final battle. Loved the serene quiet in the opening scene, Dean watching his brother in his fretful sleep, afraid to look away for fear of losing him. Counting things, keeping track - a reflection of Dean counting down his own time, perhaps? Silent memories of his father niggling at the back of his mind.  And then we see Sam’s silent struggle, wrestling with his lost faith – in himself, in God, trying to steel himself for battle against this fallen angel, against losing his brother to damnation. Those quiet scenes are truly the calm before the storm. Brilliant.

 

 

I thought that the way Sam solved the riddle was very clever – cemeteries are where people go to forgive. That is Sam’s reality; Dean’s is that he needs to stay away from the reality that death is final, that he will no longer be able to be with his loved one. And, oh, how it tugged at my heart when Dean admits to Sam that he needed him and Sam tells him that he’s always needed him. “Dean stared at him for a moment, letting those words spill over him and fill him. He’d needed to hear that. Probably more than Sam would ever understand” Oh Dean.

 

 

The final battle in the mausoleum was absolutely breath-stealing, just phenomenal. Literally good versus evil, love versus hate, faith versus doubt, rage versus control. Such powerful emotions so perfectly played out in a battle of wills with Dean’s life as the “prize”.  Man, you put Dean through the wringer and then wrung him out some more! Thank God Dean was able to get through to Sam before he became the victim of “Wrath” - “Sam, I need you to believe” and “Sam, you’re my faith”. My heart broke for Sam when he held his dying brother in his arms after defeating the fallen angel: “I prayed every day, and I’m still going to lose you”

 

 

All’s well that ends well. I have to admit that the whole “white light” healing thing was a bit out there (Mulder alert!), but since I didn’t want Dean to die, I’ll take it on faith ;). Fabulous, amazing chapter – definitely one for the annuls. You ladies seriously rock. Looking forward to the epilogue as this story draws to a close. I, for one, will be so sorry to see it end. This has been the best kickass story I’ve read in a long time. Until next time…

Author's Response:

Oh, Irish, thank you so much for this detailed review! I simply loved your interpretation of the emotions and discussions we wove through the chapter. So glad you enjoyed the final battle. When we were plotting this out, it was never a question in our minds that Sam would be Wrath, but we knew we had to be careful to balance what we know of Dean and what we know of Sam to what the situation was going to push both of them toward.

And I'll take a faith-based outlook on the white-light healing any day. Loved the Mulder reference -- ha! We know how easy it is to write darkness and how hard it is to believe in light. We wanted them to actually have a miracle, just this one time.

Thanks so much for the kickass comment! That made me laugh out loud. We so appreciate your reading and your faithful feedback. Hope you enjoy the epilogue!

Slainte,

Gaelic and SJ

 
Reviewer: Huntergal Signed
Date: 20/01/08 Title: Chapter 8: Benediction

Benediction – what a perfect title with its dual meaning – a blessing and giving praise. Both boys’ discussion about what Dean’s healing was about – could it mean that there is a higher power, something that may save them both? Of course, Sam still has more faith than Dean, believes that Dean’s healing was a blessing. I just loved the “Butch and Sundance” reference – only Dean would think that because we didn’t see them die, that perhaps they didn’t die. Dean believes in what he can see – including the goodness of his brother – his faith, his hope. I like that Dean comes to believe that perhaps he does have a second chance, that there is hope that Sam will find a way to save him from his deal.

 

 

Apparently there’s no rest for the wicked ;), because our boys are off to fight a demon before they’ve even had time to recover after “playing Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman” - love the shout out to “Se7en”. Poor Dean can never catch a break – the demon taunts and tortures him – but the boys win over evil once again. I liked that when Dean was looking at the stars’ light, he thought that perhaps the good he’s done will live after him like the light of long dead stars. And it renews his faith to keep on fighting the good fight for how ever long he has.

 

 

Well, ladies, it was one helluva ride! This story was amazing – it had it all – angst, hurt, fear, brotherly love, banter, and some really deep discussions of faith and hope that give us more insight into the boys. You both have done a tremendous job with co-writing and putting this all together into one of the best stories I’ve read. I watched SJ’s video – very well done. Thank you for sharing this phenomenal story with us. I’ll be looking forward to future stories from both of you. Until next time…

Author's Response:

Ach, Irish, there you are. I was so hoping we'd see you here at the end!

Thank you so much for calling out the parts you enjoyed. That really makes us grin! Dean and his movies, the boys and their faith, and musing about the constancy of starlight... *claps* just love that you enjoyed all of that!

SJ's video was fantastic.:) SO glad you enjoyed that. As I said below... somewhere... we're be co-writing a story for the VS Season 3 that will air mid-March and then SJ will be continuing on with that team while I will be off to explore some solo fanfic. :)

If you read, we both truly hope you enjoy as we've enjoyed hearing from you. Your reviews are always so thoughtful and well-put. It's a true joy to receive them.

Slainte,

Gaelic and SJ