Supernaturalville
Reviews For Gifts
Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 14/04/10 06:55 AM · On: Breaking

One of the things that had been slamming in his chest since it happened, fluttering against his heart, making it ache, was suddenly gone.  Sam was still Sam. "I miss her, too," Sam said softly.   "Hey, don't offend the car4, she thinks she's an Impala and I'm not telling her any different."  Dean chuckled and opened the door.  Finally they talk bring their love for the Impala out in the open.  It's been this huge elephant in the room whenever they travel and no one ever addresses it.  And even funnier, is that Sam refers to the Impala as 'her' even though he makes fun of Dean for doing just that. The conversation in the car when Dean feels Sam's eyes staring at him was brilliant.  "You were staring loud.  A smile spread across Sam's face.  "You can't stare loud, Dean."  "Yeah you can, Sammy, and you stare loudest of all."  I laughed with tears in my eyes.  "...and surprise, surprise, Dean was downplaying the injury."  We've seen this so often on the show, Sam getting frustrated with Dean for ignoring serious injuries and Dean plugging along, denying anything is wrong.  This little snippet was so Sam and Dean. "We're still a team, Sam and that's all that matters."  We're still..." Sam began.  Something in his chest snapped, he wasn't sure what it was, but the tears broke loose and he started trembling..."  That was the best thing Dean could have said!  I think Sam's been waiting to see if he had any value but he's been measuring himself by the wrong standard.  he could still hunt, he was still a vital part of team Winchester.  When you describe the scent of cinnamon rolls mixed with Dean's leather jacket, I could smell it myself.  I felt the peace and security that Sam must have felt.  Another little touch that makes you the master.   OMGOMGOMGOMG!  Sam did it!  He stood, walked---all for Dean, all to help his big brother.  and the icing is that he's getting better.  The infections is clearing!  Yahoooo!        

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 09:36 PM · On: The Biggest Gift

Marvelous!

"It made sense, more than that, it gave him a feeling of being in control, this was his element, it was what he did, in a large way, it was who he was, and the fact he could use this to help Sam made it even better."  That passage expressed what Dean feels so perfectly!

He wanted his brother, needed Sam to wake up, wanted him to fight.  Please was becoming the only word he knew.  He'd meant everything he said to Sam, he hoped his brother knew that, hoped that... Oh god, Sammy.  Another passage that exquisitely describes Dean's pain, uncertainty and need.

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 09:06 PM · On: Making Breakfast

Awww.  I loved this chapter!  it was so hopeful.  Both men just being brothers again and enjoying one another's company.  

Car hops in short pink skirts?  No wonder Dean had to stop.  The kid's meal for Sam was great!  Not only was it a good joke but it was probably all he'd be able to eat anyway. 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 08:07 PM · On: Answers

"I know what kind of you are, Dean."  True fact!  No one knows Dean better than Sam.

Okay so what's the difficult part of the ritual?  There has to be something dangerous and strange. 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 07:32 PM · On: You Made...?

I started to review this but had to stop and make supper only to find it had been closed.  GRRRRR!   So hopefully, I'll remeber the key points I wanted to mention.

How sad for Dean to have to see his brother suffer and know that Sam woulod be able to find the cure to save him if only he weren't so depressed.  Time is ticking away and all Dean can do is fight to keep his brother alive long enough to save him, keep him comfortable and keep his spirits up.

And Alan experienced first hand the painful way Sam is going to die.  Now he has to sit back and watch both men suffer.

"He wasn't fighting for himself, he was fighting because of Dean.  He could do that much at least, his brother had given him so much, he could do this.  That way when...At least Dean will know..."  that's always one thing the Winchesters fight for no matter how the odds are stacked against them---one another.  Now maybe Sam will kick this infection in the ass.

An answer?  Yippeee!  

  

Reviewer: supernaturalfan (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 02:08 PM · On: Cookies

Great chapter Muffy.  I've been missing it, so I was excited you posted another. Those are some of my favorite cookies, and loved that they held a special memory for the boys. I remember making them alot when I was a kid, too. I'm glad Sam is finally getting better. You had me worried there for awhile. Look forward to your next chapter. Take Care.
Jane 

Reviewer: bitnblue (Signed) · Date: 13/04/10 12:42 AM · On: Cookies

a new installment, yipee! who knew sam could make cookies... well, we all knew dean would love to eat said cookies - he does, after all have a sweet tooth. keep it coming, this is one of the few stories i've managed to keep up with during this semester at school and i find myself looking forward to each chapter!

Reviewer: Primrose (Signed) · Date: 12/04/10 04:26 PM · On: Cookies

My favorite cookie!  How wonderful that there's finally hope for Sam!

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 10/04/10 10:49 PM · On: On Giving Up

What were Nate and Sam discussing that made Sam decide to fight?  I ,love the end!  "If it ends, we go down fighting?"  "Yeah, Dean, we go down fighting."  Hooray!!  the Winchesters are back!  Watch out world!

Does the color of Nate's car have anything to do with the smoke or the infection or a trigger to solve Sam's problem.

And where is Dean's baby?  Who has it?  How will he get it back?  He mentioned that she'll be well cared for but that's vague and all so sad.

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 10/04/10 10:07 PM · On: Kitten of Destruction

Lots of humor and sadness in this chpater.  Fim gives hours of entertainment.  I'm glad Sam's noticed (after dean pointed it out) that he uses his left hand when he isn't paying attention to his actions.  That shows there's improvement.

I feel so sorry for both men.  they're being drained physically and emotionally.  Hopefully, this latest development (the red smoke) will peak Sam's interest enough to get him into research mode.  That will give him a sense of empowerment.  

How sad for Alan.  His wife's dead and he knows that Sam has the same illness, that he got it from Carrie.  That's a lot of guilt to carry with you. 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 09/04/10 06:54 AM · On: Panic Attacks

So much happening--events slamming into both boys at the pace of a speeding bullet.  Wonderful tension!  You had me on the edge of my seat the entire time.

Poor Dean, he must have felt so guilty not being able to be the one in control after Sam's attack.  and then he had to show his vulnerability to others---so not cool.  But I loved that his human side came out.  There's so many times that Sam and Dean have courage and fortitude beyond human endurance.  It's nice to see they're still just men with fears, and weaknesses, and no real control of life. 

I feel sorry for Alan, too.  I can't imagine the guilt that he's been carrying around, the drive to heal Sam as redemption for what his wife has done.  Now, when his wife is so close to death, his focus is taken away from her.  I'm sure he wants to be with her every moment.  He seems like a decent man.  You can tell that he has no hesitation in coming to the aid of his friends but you know that deep in his mind, he's counting the minutes remaining in his wife's life.

Dean calling Alan a bastard before he conked out was spot on.  You know he'd be pissed.  and we all know that giving Dean the good meds would be the only way to get him to relax when Sam's in crisis.

Red smoke?!  You pop the surprises in where we least expect them.  Just when I start to think I know where you're going with this, you shoot me a curve.

Dean going to the ER to end Sam's shooter was so Dean Winchester.  And then Sam volunteers to help Alan, push away the feelings of betrayal to do what he know is right---help a friend and fight evil.  It'll be his big 'screw you' to the thing that injured him in the first place.

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 08/04/10 07:51 PM · On: Fetching

What a wonderful way for Dean to wake up, listening to Sam laugh and play with the cat.  That's a good start to the day.

Yay Sam!  Clearing the table was a big step for him.  He should be able to feel a sense of usefulness, begin to feel good about himself again.

OH MY STARS!!!!!  The woman who shot Sam is Alan's wife?! Amazing!  I'm speechless.  Just have a million more questions---the main one is why did she shoot Sam?  Was she possessed?

I hate having to share a computer!!  I want to read your story in one sitting but I have to share the computer.  I'm lucky to get one chapter a day read.  Maybe if I stay up late and get up extra early... 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 08/04/10 06:50 AM · On: Awakenings

The entire conversation between the brothers over Fim's roast beef kill was hilarious!  I had to read it twice and laughed just as hard the second time.  "There are no herds of roast beef in the wild.  Don't use the Sammy logic on me."  It's good to see that Sam and Dean are still the same people in a more domesticated situation as they are on the road.  You reinforce that in so many little ways throughout the story.

I was so touched when Sam wondered if he'd been buried beside his Jess.  His mother's grave would be empty but Jess...her body would be there.  Sometimes I forget about her. 

The terrible monster that was going to tear Sam limb from limb was Dean's snoring?  Fabulously funny and yet so natural. 

There couldn't have been a sweeter response to "who am I to you" than "jerk"!  Woot!  Woot!  Especially after Dean felt "a punch coming on." 

You have me so totally immersed in this story.  I'm crying and cheering and holding my breath with the Winchesters.  Every victory is my victory and every time Dean waits for Sam to do something, nod, speak, walk, I find myself tense with anticipation and unable to breathe until I read that he's accomplished the task.

Now that I know the main body of Sam's situation, each little piece that fills in more detail has me appreciating more and more the strength, determination and perseverance of  Sam and Dean.

I'm still anxious and eagerly awaiting word on what happened to the bitch who shot Sam.  And what did Dean do to her? 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 07/04/10 04:27 PM · On: Confessions and Realizations

Fim---perfect name for the cat.  I'm not a cat person and apparently Dean isn't either.

Who does Alan have to check on?  he stopped pretty abruptly when he was talking to Dean in the kitchen.  Did Dean hunt down the shooter?

Calmly, propelled calmly.  Too funny!  I could see it in my mind.

Geez, what a brilliant idea!  Making Sam promise not to try to kill himself while Dean was away.  Sam's confession that he thinks he was actually trying to kill himself was shocking!  I honestly believed he was trying to do something on his own.  

Thanks for letting us all know how bad Sam's injuries were.  He's made incredible progress!  Yay Sammy!

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 07/04/10 07:02 AM · On: French Toast and Surprises

You described Sam's battle with depression and his health so exquisitely.  You must have experienced this trial yourself to have spoken about it so meaningfully.

I was impressed by Sam's thoughts of Dean and what he's going through.  It truly shows the depth of their bond for Sam to think outside himself when suffering from such a deep depression.  I'm glad you brought up the Impala again.  It was so important to both men that I imagine they would think of it and mourn its loss.  I especially liked that you included it as a member of their family.  It was their home their entire lives.

Dean's laughter at Sam's wimpery, resigned "Okay, Dan." was just what both men needed.  I love how you balance the dark moods with little snippets of humor.  It flows very smoothly and realistically.

"Looks all thaw-y.  I know you don't recognize it but that's chef talk."  Hilarious!  It's so good to see them joking with one another again.  It eases the weight of the burdens they bear.  And I loved that you topped off that conversation with a loving, "bit me."

I had to smile at Sam's light-hearted words when he found out Dean had punched the wall. I was afraid he'd become morose.  Good thing Dean's around to keep those walls in line. 

Loads of surprises.  Dean working.  A new kitten.  Sam using his left hand to pet it.  Lots of small victories. 

How horrible for Dean to live under the fear that his brother tried to kill himself.  That would be crushing after almost losing him once, after fighting so hard to keep him alive, after sacrificing so much to make change their lives to accommodate Sam's new needs.  I hope he learns the truth soon.

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 05/04/10 05:38 PM · On: An Evening at Home

Awww!  Poor Sammy.  How awful to have to relive that moment.  Now he know that the woman intended to kill him.  So smart of Dean to let Sam have privacy to let it all out.  It was so sweet of Dean clue Sam in that he was coming back and then give him extra time to compose himself while he put away clothing and fixed supper.  Apparently, Dean also needs to deal with what happened, what is happening now.

"And a movie?"    "You think this is a date?"  Laugh riot!  And so appropriate for Dean to back away from the emotions.

"Don't," Sam's quiet plea stopped him.  "Don't try to feed me, Dean, I couldn't take it," Sam said desperately.  I felt my heart sink, tears rubbing the backs of my eyes.  But Dean thinks quick on his feet, relying on hunter instinct he lies and goes to Plan B.  Yay Team Dean!

Sam is trying so hard.  You know it's for Dean.

"You remembered," Sam whispered, he looked up, his eyes bright.   "Yeah."  Another awww moment for the brothers.  Another opportunity for Dean to show Sam that he's important.  And I was wondering why Dean had gone to the thrift store.

Those poor boys!  Sam is completely wiped out by pain and the challenges that he faces.  I was surprised that Dean had built a hiding place for Sam's meds.  It was a smart idea but only goes to prove how despondent Sam is.  

So the shooter got away, huh?  She'd better fly to a remote island in the Pacific because that's the only way she'll evade Dean. 


Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 05/04/10 04:41 PM · On: Macaroni and Cheese

Dean eating healthy break chalk full of protein and grains and nuts?  Now that's love!

"There, Dean, can I have dessert now?"  Hee!  Good one Sammy.  and Dean just takes it in stride. An angry Sam is better than a hopeless Sam.

Another great memory!  Dean trying to help Sam with comfort food that will remind him of good times is a marvelous idea!  Who doesn't need comfort food?  I thought it was funny that Sam thought macaroni and cheese only came from a box.

"The bartender was pretty, with eyes the color of the first girl Dean had been with.  Funny, I remember that.  maybe it's one of those things you always remember, like the first time you drive, the first time you hear a gunshot, the first time you torch a ghost."  A clever touch!  I love the little details you add.  And I love that you put things we could relate to along with those that would be exclusively hunter-related.

Finally, we find out what happened.  Now we have to find out why and who.  Apparently she got away.  Was she shooting Sam for something he did or to hurt Dean? 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 05/04/10 04:15 PM · On: Yellow Walls

i love that you started this chapter on a high note.  Sam wakes up disoriented, expecting the depressing hospital and all his problems and he hears a sound he's heard his entire life---Dean snoring.  Something normal and reassuring.  Now he knows he's home and safe.

Dean is such a sweetie!  The yellow walls and plaid curtains in their room shows that he was listening, that even small things are important to him where his brother is concerned.  Even though it's his idea of hell he did it.  And the fact that in Sam's mind it represents home shows how much Dean is trying to make everything perfect for Sam's recovery, make up for everything he's been denied growing up that Dean wasn't able to provide.  Come to think of it, I've never been in a yellow hotel room either.

 Roasted chicken and now special pancakes?  I would have Christo'd him too.  I think he's been possessed by Martha Stewart.

"The way he said it, Sam suddenly understood that Dean knew...Knew what this meant."  There's only so much a person can take before they feel totally useless.  Showering by yourself and wiping your own butt are two very important facts. this is just another example of how much Dean loves his brother and wants to help him recover.  I also like that he mentions to Sam that he used it a couple of times so Sam doesn't feel like he's being labeled 'handicapped'.

Yay!  In the kitchen during breakfast, the Winchesters were back to normal, talking and joking. "Okay, want to take a walk?  Or want to be hooked up behind the car and towed?  Dean asked, bringing Sam his coat and hat."       "Towed."       "You got it, bitch, but when the chair rolls over and your knees get skinned, don't come crying to me."  Fabulous!  I died laughing.

Do we ever find out why Dean calls the nurse Pooh? 

oooh!  How dirty!  Another hint about what happened to Sam.  Now we know it involves some skanky woman who seems to be human.  Did she drug him?  Stab him in the back?  Was she a meatsuit for Meg or some other demon?  Maybe vampire Kate? 

I was cheering for Sam when Dean was counting down the seconds.  and then he stood longer than the extra three seconds.  He's trying to get better for Dean, trying not to disappoint his big brother.

You mean we finally get to find out what happened?  yahooo! 

Burgers and classic rock---hell yeah!  Count me in.  There's only so long you can stay in a bar playing country music. Blech! 

Car orgasm--hilarious!!  But who wouldn't be interested in taking a look at a '63 Impala?  I'll bet even Sam looked.

He felt Dean's hands on his throat, part of his brain told him.  I wonder if he'll find one?  Sam took a shallow breath, it sighed out of him.  He couldn't draw another.  the last sensation was Dean's hands wrenching his head back, and the world was gone."  Aughhh!  Tear my heart out.  Hurt, dying Sam, crying Dean, it's so beautifully sad.

When Sammy says maybe he should have died, that was awful.  It's the depression talking because we all know Winchesters fight to the end.

"Dean met his eyes.  "Yeah, Sammy, I know I can."  Hoo ha!  Get 'em Dean!  I believe he can, too. 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 04/04/10 07:47 PM · On: First Day Home

Very vague tantalizing hints about what happened.  I'm so eager to find out what happened.  Was it supernatural or human?

Dean has done so much to make a good home for Sam.  It's very touching to see this dimension of the Winchester's bond.  I hate to see Sam so despondent but I know after an enormous amount of angst he'll work it out.  

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 04/04/10 09:21 AM · On: Home Coming

Dean sold the Impala?!  How tragic!  As if Sam doesn't feel guilty enough, knowing Dean sold his most prized possession must be killing him.  I understand why Dean did it (for the money?) but it's one of the few possessions they have and it's been their home for so long.  Think of all the memories attached to the Impala.  *sigh*

I hate sharing a computer!  I'll have to get back to the story later.  IhopeIhopeIhope! 

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 04/04/10 08:55 AM · On: The Impala

already with this first chapter my heart is pounding and I read hesitantly, afraid at what I'd discover.  I don't like it (well, yes I do because it's going to be an incredible story but I don't like what's happening to the boys).  Sam incapacitated, Dean needing special training to care for him, and worst of all no Impala?!  The horror!

Now I need to find out what happened and how the Winchesters are going to triumph. 

Reviewer: bitnblue (Signed) · Date: 01/04/10 11:40 PM · On: Breaking

Now that the meds are working... what next? please keep it coming!

Reviewer: zz1989 (Signed) · Date: 21/03/10 06:27 AM · On: The Biggest Gift

I hope you'll update this story soon.  Poor Sam, and poor Dean trying to keep his brother fighting to stay alive.  

Reviewer: Micaiah (Signed) · Date: 07/03/10 09:48 PM · On: Breaking

Yay!  I'm finally caught up on this story!  Poor Dean.  I thought he'd gotten really bad news but finally they've gotten some good news!

I love the kitten in this story.  Reminds me so much of my own.

Reviewer: Primrose (Signed) · Date: 22/02/10 01:38 PM · On: Breaking

Hooray!  Good news finally!  I have gotten so far behind following this story!  I just started over and read from the beginning.  What a great job you are doing!  Loving it!

Author's Response: Oh thank you so much!

You must login (register) to review.