Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 29/07/10 09:06 AM · On: Joshua's Legacy: Patriarchal Lineage

A very sweet story!  I love how Joshua took the negatives of his childhood and used them positively.  And that he's careful not to prejudice Max's opinion of Harland or the Brotherhood.

Joshua's such a good father.  I've alwasy thought it was funny that the thing (the craft) that Harland tried to suppress was the same thing that made Joshua part of the current Triad.

Reviewer: fredo (Signed) · Date: 22/06/09 01:42 PM · On: Joshua's Legacy: Patriarchal Lineage

Another great one. Caleb and Joshua, brothers... And I love how they have raised their kids. And nice to have a glimpse of the girls. Loved it.

Reviewer: fredo (Signed) · Date: 11/05/09 02:50 PM · On: Chapter 7: Reprieved

What a pleasure! I hope you'll get lots of other requests...

Reviewer: fredo (Signed) · Date: 05/04/09 08:34 AM · On: All Grown Up

Loved it, very good one. Joshua and Esme's relation is a huge part of the character. Btw if you're opened to suggestions, what Joshua thinks of Mac and Esme, and even about Caleb as a new family is something I'd like to read about... Anyway, thanks, these chronicles are great!

Reviewer: Midge (Signed) · Date: 03/04/09 03:59 PM · On: All Grown Up

Please Tidia, can you try to correct the formatting in this post. It really is tough to read at the moment, and I really want to enjoy it to its full potential.

Thanks, I will be back.

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 28/03/09 09:29 PM · On: Otherwise Engaged

It's strange and yet kind of cozy the way Joshua and Caleb have laid aside their hostilities toward one another and formed a genuine, amicable relationship.

The joke about Esme being pregnant was hilarious!

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 28/03/09 07:10 PM · On: The Phone Rings. . .

I love reading stories from different points of view!  I don't think Joshua gets enough credit or air time.  I think he'll be a valuable advisor and I see him working well with the Winchesters and Caleb.  They need someone to balance out their impetuousness.

Reviewer: fredo (Signed) · Date: 24/03/09 06:02 AM · On: Chapter 4 Christmas Time 2008

Very good one again, interesting to see things from Joshua's point of view, and to have more insight about his life. And two more to come, that's very good news...

Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed) · Date: 17/02/09 04:52 PM · On: Chapter 2

Nice to see Joshua and Carolyn together.  We hear of their involvement but unfortunately don't get to see it.  It's nice that there's one fairly stable relationship in the Brotherhood.

Reviewer: fredo (Signed) · Date: 10/01/09 07:30 AM · On: Chapter 2

Again, great. Nice to see Esme and Carolyn. And happy to see even Josh is on 'team Mackland'! Feel free to add as many things as you want, I'd love to read one about how he found out about Dean's return and his reaction, or even what his thoughts were after his little trip to Porter and Harland with the new Guardian...

Reviewer: lynne88 (Signed) · Date: 09/01/09 06:04 PM · On: Revelations

Thank you so much for sharing this. I abosulutely loved these stories. I hope you can do some more pieces from Joshua's point of view. I have enjoyed all your stories, but my favorites have been the ones with Josh. You really seem to hit your stride with this character. 

Reviewer: devonshire (Signed) · Date: 08/01/09 10:19 PM · On: Revelations

i read this at ff.net and reviewed it there, but after reading it again i have so much more to say. 

i loved the interaction between josh and esme, it was a little window into the 'normal' of their lives we never get to see. loved her shop and hearing josh talk about her.

i also loved joshua's weariness of the coven and him thinking back to one of john's orders about not going in without intell.

it was really a nice window into a character that's normally very secretive.