Supernaturalville
Reviews For Beneath the Hollow
Reviewer: NongPradu (Signed) · Date: 03/04/09 04:39 PM · On: Sympathy for the Devil

Quick question: are we going to see Alex Masters again?  I'd really like to see Dean kick the crap out of him for threatening Charlotte.  ;)

 

 



Author's Response: He will be showing up again.  I can't say anything else beyond that, though I can confirm that Dean would know *want* to kick the crap out of him for threatening Charlotte...

Reviewer: gengen0776 (Signed) · Date: 14/01/09 09:47 AM · On: The Shapes Between Us Turn Into Animals

A lot going on in this chapter! Poor Dean and Charlotte, John is really working a number on them. Glad too see Dean sticking by Charlie though! I seriously wanted to smack John though he can be one cold hearted bastard! Looking forward to more! Gen

Author's Response:

I'm trying to work through the setup of the Roadhouse as John's base of operations, and things sort of blew up in this chapter. ;)

I was actually a little suprised when Dean went against his father's wishes, but based on the way his character has developed in the story, it does make a certain amount of sense.  And he does have a unique insight into the situation as far as Charlotte is concerned.

Though, I have to confess, I think John *needs* to be as hard as he is in this story because of what they're up against.  He knows the truth of the power the Circle can bring to bear and he is driven by self-sacrifice.  I like to think he does the best he can under extraordinary circumstances.

And there is another chapter already posted.  Given my writing schedule, though, I'm posting other vignettes that take place within this story (during unspecified times) while I get my writing mojo back for the main storyline. ;)

Plus, there's always my AU of this 'verse.  (Yes, I wrote an AU of an AU.  I'm just that crazy.)

Reviewer: NongPradu (Signed) · Date: 13/01/09 11:48 PM · On: Into the Fire

Holy rusted metal Batman!

I'm totally freaked out about this Awakening business now!  Have I got it right that the only way they're not totally freaking doomed is if they manage to Awaken before Shamhezai rises?  If they Awaken they can't be taken over?

Let's get them good and Awoken, then!  lol.

I loved John in this chapter -- so raw and protective and at the same time totally wrecked.  Like this scary pillar of strength, and at the same time a dried husk of a man.  It's sort of exactly how I picture him.  Some people tend to portray John as being more of a hard-ass than I think was really earned on the show, especially if you consider how often we see him cry.  (More in a few episodes than Dean does in the entire series, I think).  So yeah, the emotional wreck you've conjured here is sort of picture perfect and totally in character.  He'd have to be both rigidly hard and at the same time weepy and vulnerable to have earned both his reputation and Dean's unwavering faith and devotion.

But at the same time, he's sort of a crap father, too.  lol.  I mean, poor Dean looks in the mirror and hates what he sees.  So there's some definite neglect issues going on with the poor kid, and I'd say John's treatment of him is probably largely to blame.

The psychology of the Winchesters never ceases to amaze me.  Seriously.  And to bring it back to this wonderfully freaky tale of yours, I think you've been playing with the psychological quagmire that is Winchesterdom wonderfully.  It hurts to read sometimes because it's so raw, but kind of exquisite at the same time.



Author's Response:

*Have I got it right that the only way they're not totally freaking doomed is if they manage to Awaken before Shamhezai rises?  If they Awaken they can't be taken over?*

You are, indeed, correct.  On both counts. 

*I loved John in this chapter -- so raw and protective and at the same time totally wrecked.*

Whew.  My biggest fear with this installment in the series is that someone will consider my portrayal of John to be "John-bashing" - which is the last thing I wanted people to think.  I personally believe that John - on the show as well as in this series - truly cares about his sons and is driven to fight an essentially unbeatable foe given what the Circle can bring to bear. 

I actually tried to show this through Charlotte, who also has an understanding of what they're truly up against.  She believes in his cause if not his methods - and it doesn't matter that he will probably *never* trust her completely...

*And to bring it back to this wonderfully freaky tale of yours, I think you've been playing with the psychological quagmire that is Winchesterdom wonderfully.  It hurts to read sometimes because it's so raw, but kind of exquisite at the same time.*

That psychology degree of mine does get put to good use in this story.  I think characters with true flaws are much more interesting to write than not, and I tried to extrapolate from the show how they would react in this situation - Sam wanting the normal while dealing with the big bad inside of him (literally) and Dean having to deal with his emotional distance by being forced to do it.  And John.  He was the hardest of all.

And I always try to be honest with the psychological stuff in my stories.  Even when it is so raw.  Writing some of the things I've written in the last two years hasn't been easy. ;)

Woo-hoo!  Another novel!  I really do need to send your e-mail address to work so I can write you novels on my lunch hour.

Reviewer: NongPradu (Signed) · Date: 12/01/09 12:47 PM · On: The Shapes Between Us Turn Into Animals

Excellent chapter.  Gosh, this is pretty intense, huh?  John Winchester scares me a bit in this story.  I wish they'd do a John Winchester spin-off or something, where we could see what he was up to while the boys were kids.  I bet he was one scary mofo.  Seriously.

Can't wait for the next installment!



Author's Response:

Thanks!  (Though, as I said, the next chapter is the last one for awhile - though there's vignettes and an AU of this 'verse I can post in the interim... )

Writing John in this story terrifies me.  I tried to approach him as living with extraordinary circumstances and doing his best to cope with what was left.  

Reviewer: NongPradu (Signed) · Date: 12/01/09 11:06 AM · On: Sympathy for the Devil

GAH!!!  I don't know how I missed that you had started posting this!

Totally freaky beginning!  I'm already terrified!  Seriously, this story is so intense, the bad guys so seriously evil and freaky, that my stomach twists up when I read.  You're so good at writing in the dark stuff.

And by the by, you still owe me an e-mail.  ;)



Author's Response:

I do still owe you an e-mail, though you may be angry with me.  I've posted the last chapter I've written for this story tonight - and I'm working to get my writing mojo back in order so I can finish my multi-chaptered stories.  Can't help when you get sick, I guess...

But I am glad that the bad guys are freaky.  I worked hard to make them otherworldly.  And I do wish there was a tag for "horror" since I do write a lot of it in addition to the romance and the funny. ;)

Reviewer: gengen0776 (Signed) · Date: 09/01/09 06:37 AM · On: Sympathy for the Devil

Nice! I couldn`t stay away...what can I say I am weak! But this way you get a review for each chapter!  ;) Great title for the chapter! I LOVE that song!

Very interesting take here that the WHOLE masters family serves Azazeal...Yup your AU just gets better and better!

Keep up the good work! Gen



Author's Response:

*hee*

The Masters family connection made sense once I sat down and figured out who the Circle worked.

But, seriously, there's no need to review every chapter.   Just knowing that you like the story works for me. ;)

You must login (register) to review.