Reviewer: drkstormynite (Signed)
24/06/08 10:51 AM · On:
Exactly how I pictured it! Poor Bobby, wants to help our boys so much. Thank you for a great little short shot.
Reviewer: impalamedean1 (Signed)
11/06/08 11:08 AM · On:
I loved this story!! you did an amazing awesome wonderful job!! keep up the AWESOME WORK!!
Author's Response: glad you liked it =-)
Reviewer: supernatgrl13 (Signed)
29/05/08 04:33 PM · On:
Ahhhh!! Poor Dean! That episode made me cry!! Good job getting into Bobby's head; I can totally imagine him thinking that way. Good job!!
Author's Response: Thank-you!
Reviewer: TozaBoma (Signed)
18/05/08 11:02 AM · On:
I love Bobby, and he never gets enough page-time, LOL
This was absolutely fab, nicely done! I got the feeling he made sure he never cracked in front of The Boys, even AHBL 1+2.
Superb. Ta for sharing.
Author's Response: Bobby rocks! lol. Thanks for reviewing!
Reviewer: zerosbabe (Signed)
10/05/08 09:16 PM · On:
Great story and you caught the emotions just great. Well deserved being posted on the features.
Thanks so much :) I'm glad you think so!
Reviewer: mymuseandi (Signed)
10/05/08 04:17 AM · On:
Lovely short story....i love Bobby's point of view, more so when it's Dean Winchester's that he's musing about... :)
Author's Response: glad you enjoyed it :)
Reviewer: CdeWinter78 (Signed)
06/05/08 06:57 PM · On:
This was a wonderful insight into the POV of such a great enigma... and his hat gets a mention too! Seriously though - I love the character of Bobby, he really did shine in AHBL2 and Mr Bever did such justice to the role. Your story takes it a step further and gives us an image of what Bobby may have gone through when one brother was lost and the other too far gone. The way he remains there for Dean, holding it all and instinctively knowing when to help and when to back off, is a really powerful picture of the depth of feeling he has for these boys - and your superb writing gives us all that and more. Loved your ending were Bobby realises this is probably the end for both brothers as "he knows in his heart that losing one means losing both". Great job - deserving of it's feature.
Author's Response: All of the amazing reviews this has got is seriously making me blush. This honestly was just written out of the blue in an attempt to get my muse back, so the feature was a huge surprise. Thanks so much for the lengthy review! *hugs*
Reviewer: birdie (Signed)
06/05/08 02:39 PM · On:
We all know that Bobby is a good man and a good surrogate father to both boys and you have captured that here. It's a wonderful and terrible scene in the epi and so well acted and you captured the continuation of that emotional scene very appropriately with your words.
Thanks you for sharing.
Author's Response: Thanks Bird :D I appreciate the kind review!
Reviewer: Dottyoz (Signed)
06/05/08 11:59 AM · On:
That was beautifully written, just the right length. Not really thought about Bobby's point of view before but I think you got it spot on.
Author's Response: Thank-you! I'm glad you didn't think it was too short :)
Reviewer: Hunter4Life (Signed)
05/05/08 06:55 PM · On:
Awww Dean! Well written! =-b
Author's Response: Glad you liked it :)
Reviewer: darkhunter (Signed)
05/05/08 05:44 PM · On:
so very sad but beautifuly written.
Author's Response: Thanks!!
Reviewer: Vanessa (Signed)
05/05/08 04:42 PM · On:
OMG! The ending of AHBL Part 1 and beginning of AHBL Part 2 just tear me up inside. It doesn't ever seem to matter that we've come so far beyond it, I still get absolutely choked up watching it or reading about it.
It was wonderful to see it all from Bobby's perspective.
Author's Response: It tears me up inside too :( I'm glad you liked it.
Reviewer: Shannondoah (Signed)
05/05/08 04:37 PM · On:
"the only remaining Winchester"---what cruel swords!
So wonderfully sad!
Author's Response: Thanks for reviewing!
Reviewer: bulletbabe (Signed)
05/05/08 04:18 PM · On:
Nicely done and yup, very angsty but just the way I like it...and any story featuring Bobby is all right by me...
Author's Response: Glad you enjoyed Bobbys perspective; it's my first time writing him.
Reviewer: Soennelchen (Signed)
05/05/08 07:27 AM · On:
You had me choking up here...
....he knows in his heart that losing one means losing both. - how true...
What a great read - thanks for sharing this with us!
..and thank you for reviewing!
Reviewer: Birdy (Signed)
05/05/08 06:44 AM · On:
Oh wow, that was fantastic! A unique perspective on Sam's death.
Thank you for posting this.
Heh...glad you enjoyed it =)
Reviewer: Cookie6 (Signed)
05/05/08 06:27 AM · On:
God Grief, you have just shot us back to that moment like we've only just finished watching. I feel the shock like its the first time. Like I have said since, Will we ever get over it?!
Your words "The sound is gut-wrenching, full of despair and denial" are perfect in describing exactly what we heard. And "Bobby never thought that Dean was capable of sounding like that" just broke my heart all over again. Awesome work!
Seeing and feeling through Bobby's eyes was an emotional experience. This very well written ficlet is very worthy of the featured status, Congratulations!
Author's Response: Thanks for reviewing; and I still can't believe it got featured!
Reviewer: kwater (Signed)
05/05/08 03:12 AM · On:
losing one means losing both,
Great line and I really enjoyed this. Thanks for the great read - Kel
Author's Response: Thanks for sending some feedback kel!
Reviewer: bambers2 (Signed)
04/05/08 10:42 PM · On:
awww...that was excellent...well deserving of a feature...awesome job!!! bambers;)
Author's Response: Thanks bambers *blush* I'm glad you liked it!
Reviewer: PropGal (Signed)
04/05/08 10:04 PM · On:
beautifully written. I loved re-examining the scene through Bobby's point of view.
well deserving of the feature.
Author's Response: Thank you! I logged on and was browsing through the feautures and was like 'waitaminute! that's mine!' I was completely surprised!